Argthtjtr

I created some systemd services which basically works:

location:

/etc/systemd/system/multi-user.target.wants/publicapi.service

content:

[Unit]

Description=public api startup script



[Service]

Type=oneshot

RemainAfterExit=yes

EnvironmentFile=-/etc/environment

WorkingDirectory=/home/techops

ExecStart=/home/techops/publicapi start

ExecStop=/home/techops/publicapi stop



[Install]

WantedBy=multi-user.target

When I try to restart the service as techops user in the command line, I get the following output:

==== AUTHENTICATING FOR org.freedesktop.systemd1.manage-units ===

Authentication is required to start 'publicapi.service'.

Multiple identities can be used for authentication:

 1.  Myself,,, (defaultuser)

 2.  ,,, (techops)

Choose identity to authenticate as (1-2):

I want that only techops can restart services and I want that this prompt does not appear when being logged in as techops. How can I do that?

I read that there are different approaches with polkit-1 or sudoers, but I'm unsure.

[UPDATE] 2019-01-27 4:40pm

Thanks for this comprehensive answer to Thomas and Perlduck. It helped me to improve my knowledge of systemd.

According to the approach to start the service without a password prompt, and I want to apologize that I did not emphasize the real problem enough:

Actually, what is most important for me is that no other user than techops should stop or start the service. But at least with the first two approaches I can still run service publicapi stop and I get the prompt ==== AUTHENTICATING FOR org.freedesktop.systemd1.manage-units === again. When I choose the defaultuser and know the password, I could stop all the services. I want to deny this user from doing that, even if he has the password. Important background info to better understand why this is the more important part for me:

The defaultuser is the only user which is exposed to ssh but this user cannot do anything else (except changing to other users if you have the password of these other users). But at the moment, he can start or stop the services, but this user must not to do this.

If someone gets the password of defaultuser and logs in via ssh, then he could stop all the services at the moment. This is what I meant with "I want that only techops can restart services". Sorry, that I was no that exact at my initial question. I thought that sudoing the techops user would maybe bypass this problem, but it does not. The problem itself is not to run the command without password prompt. (I could easily do that as techops user when I just execute /home/techops/publicapi start). The problem itself is to lock out the defaultuser from starting these services.

And I hoped that any of the solutions could do that.

I started with the approaches of Thomas.
The approach with sudo works when I don't want to get asked for the password for the user techops when I execute the commands as explained, e.g.

sudo systemctl start publicapi.service

sudo systemctl stop publicapi.service

The second approach does not work for me yet. I cannot start the service without password prompt ==== AUTHENTICATING FOR org.freedesktop.systemd1.manage-units === and I stall can login as defaultuser when I have the password of this user.

With the third approach, the service does not even start at boot process anymore so I'm not sure if this approach is the right one for me at all. I cannot even able it with systemctl enable publicapi.service which leads me to the following error:

Failed to enable unit: Unit file mycuisine-publicapi.service does not exist.

The error does no occur when I move all the services back into /etc/systemd/system/ and execute systemctl enable publicapi.service. Then the service starts again at boot.

All these approaches will more or less help to bypass the password prompt for the techops user but when I run service publicapi stop or systemctl stop publicapi with defaultuser, I can stop the services if I have the password. But my target is to lock out defaultuser from starting or stopping services at all.

To achieve that the user techops can control the service publicapi.service without giving a password, you have different possiblities. Which one is suitable for you cannot be answered as you have to choose on your own.

The classical sudo approach is maybe the most used, as it is there for a long time. You would have to create e.g. the file as follows.

Note that the drop-in directory /etc/sudoers.d is only active when #includedir /etc/sudoers.d is set in /etc/sudoers. But that should be the case if you are using a modern Ubuntu distribution. As root execute:

cat > /etc/sudoers.d/techops << SUDO

techops ALL= NOPASSWD: /bin/systemctl restart publicapi.service

techops ALL= NOPASSWD: /bin/systemctl stop publicapi.service

techops ALL= NOPASSWD: /bin/systemctl start publicapi.service

SUDO

Now you should be able to run the systemctl commands as user techops without giving a password by prepending sudo to the commands.

sudo systemctl start publicapi.service

sudo systemctl stop publicapi.service

sudo systemctl restart publicapi.service

The second method would be to use PolKit (was renamed from PolicyKit) to allow the user techops to control systemd services. Depending on the version of polit, you can give normal users control over systemd units.

To check the polkit version, just run pkaction --version.

• 
  

  with polkit version 0.106 and higher, you can allow users to control specific systemd units.
  
  To do so, you could create a rule as root:

  
  
  

  cat > /etc/polkit-1/rules.d/10-techops.rules << POLKIT
  
  polkit.addRule(function(action, subject) {
  
      if (action.id == "org.freedesktop.systemd1.manage-units" &&
  
          action.lookup("unit") == "publicapi.service" &&
  
          subject.user == "techops") {
  
          return polkit.Result.YES;
  
      }
  
  });
  
  POLKIT
  
  

  
  


• 
  

  with polkit version 0.105 and lower: you can allow users to control systemd units. This unfortunately includes all systemd units and you might not want to do this. Not sure if there is a way to limit access to specific systemd units with version 0.105 or lower, but maybe someone else can clarify.
  
  To enable this, you could create a file as root:

  
  
  

  cat > /etc/polkit-1/localauthority/50-local.d/org.freedesktop.systemd1.pkla << POLKIT
  
  [Allow user techops to run systemctl commands]
  
  Identity=unix-user:techops
  
  Action=org.freedesktop.systemd1.manage-units
  
  ResultInactive=no
  
  ResultActive=no
  
  ResultAny=yes
  
  POLKIT
  
  

  
  

In both cases you can run systemctl [start|stop|restart] publicapi.service as user techops without giving a password. In the latter case ( polkit <= 0.105 ) the user techops could control any systemd unit.

A third option would be to make the service a user service, which does not need sudo or polkit configurations. This puts everything under the control of the user and only works if your actual service that is started with /home/techops/publicapi start can run without root privileges.

First you have to enable lingering for the user techops. This is needed to startup the user service on boot. As root execute:

loginctl enable-linger techops

Next you have to move the systemd unit file into the techops user directory. As user techops execute the commands as follows.

mkdir -p ~/.config/systemd/user



cat > ~/.config/systemd/user/publicapi.service << UNIT

[Unit]

Description=public api startup script



[Service]

Type=oneshot

RemainAfterExit=yes

EnvironmentFile=-/etc/environment

WorkingDirectory=/home/techops

ExecStart=/home/techops/publicapi start

ExecStop=/home/techops/publicapi stop



[Install]

WantedBy=default.target

UNIT

Note that the WantedBy has to be default.target as there is no multi-user.target in the user context.

Now reload the configuration and enable the service. Again as user techops execute the commands.

systemctl --user daemon-reload

systemctl --user enable publicapi.service

systemctl --user start publicapi.service

In general you should place your systemd units in /etc/systemd/system/ not directly in /etc/systemd/system/multi-user.target.wants. When you execute systemctl enable publicapi.service a symbolic link will be created in etc/systemd/system/multi-user.target.wants or whatever target is specified for that unit.

As already mentioned, if the service/process itself can be run without root privileges you should consider adding User=techops to your unit file to run the process with a non-privileged user account.

First of all, you don't put a unit file in the directory
/etc/systemd/system/multi-user.target.wants. This directory is
maintained by systemd and the systemctl commands.
Put the unit file in /etc/systemd/system instead and then
enable it with

sudo systemctl enable publicapi.service

This will create a symlink below multi-user.target.wants (or wherever,
systemctl knows better) to honor the lines

[Install]

WantedBy=multi-user.target

in the unit.

Next, create a sudoers file below /etc/sudoers.d:

sudo visudo -f /etc/sudoers.d/techops

with the following content:

Cmnd_Alias HANDLE_PUBLICAPI = 

    /bin/systemctl start   publicapi.service 

    /bin/systemctl stop    publicapi.service 

    /bin/systemctl restart publicapi.service



techops ALL = (root) NOPASSWD: HANDLE_PUBLICAPI

Do not use a regular editor (e.g. sudo vim /etc/sudoers.d/techops)
to edit that file because if you put any syntax errors in it you won't
be able to run sudo again. visudo on the other hand checks the
syntax of the file before leaving the editor.

Now the user techops can run

sudo systemctl start publicapi.service

and the other two without supplying a password. Note that you must type
the command and parameters exactly as given in the sudoers file (except for
the /bin/systemctl part which can be shortened to just systemctl).

For instance, sudo /bin/systemctl start publicapi (whithout .service)
would ask for a password.