Why didn't Hermione help Dobby when his life was in danger?












19














In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1, we see Bellatrix throw a dagger after Dobby saved Harry and co., and in the aftermath we see Harry begging Hermione to give him anything that could save Dobby, but Hermione standing still.



Why is this? Is it too late for anything to be done? Is it because Dobby is not a human? We have definitely seen Hermione heal Ron before.










share|improve this question





























    19














    In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1, we see Bellatrix throw a dagger after Dobby saved Harry and co., and in the aftermath we see Harry begging Hermione to give him anything that could save Dobby, but Hermione standing still.



    Why is this? Is it too late for anything to be done? Is it because Dobby is not a human? We have definitely seen Hermione heal Ron before.










    share|improve this question



























      19












      19








      19


      1





      In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1, we see Bellatrix throw a dagger after Dobby saved Harry and co., and in the aftermath we see Harry begging Hermione to give him anything that could save Dobby, but Hermione standing still.



      Why is this? Is it too late for anything to be done? Is it because Dobby is not a human? We have definitely seen Hermione heal Ron before.










      share|improve this question















      In Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows – Part 1, we see Bellatrix throw a dagger after Dobby saved Harry and co., and in the aftermath we see Harry begging Hermione to give him anything that could save Dobby, but Hermione standing still.



      Why is this? Is it too late for anything to be done? Is it because Dobby is not a human? We have definitely seen Hermione heal Ron before.







      plot-explanation harry-potter the-deathly-hallows-1






      share|improve this question















      share|improve this question













      share|improve this question




      share|improve this question








      edited 20 hours ago









      Josh Caswell

      396316




      396316










      asked 2 days ago









      Tolga Ozses

      7903925




      7903925






















          2 Answers
          2






          active

          oldest

          votes


















          24














          Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby




          • Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn't Madam Pomfrey. Similarly, she was not able to save Snape in deathly hallows part 2.


          • Hermione was definitely in shock, because she was tortured by Bellatrix several minutes ago - she needed help herself first



          • Dittany heals a lot of things, but a knife through the chest may not be one of them. Also as Hermione mentions, it may the injuries make even worse




            " 'It's all I feel safe doing,' said Hermione shakily. 'There are
            spells that would put him completely right, but I daren't try in case
            I do them wrong and cause more damage.... He's lost so much blood
            already...."




          • Most important - she was not there while Dobby was dying at the beach, they went to house together with Ron (she is present just in the film)


          • Here is the list of all known healing spells. None of them can probably heal such a fatal injury Dobby has suffered.


          • In the book Hermione stuffed the beaded bag in her sock to save it. In the film, the snatchers got the beaded bag.





          Further reading




          • Science Fiction and Fantasy: Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?

          • Quora: Why didn't Hermione heal Dobby in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1?






          share|improve this answer























          • I always figured Dittany was just for Apparition
            – Azor Ahai
            2 days ago










          • @AzorAhai > There may be a certain amount of scarring, but if you take dittany immediately we might avoid even that.. Severus Snape to Draco Malfoy after Sectumsempra, HBP.
            – Bob
            yesterday












          • @AzorAhai Hermione also used it to treat the burns the trio got while breaking into Gringotts, as well as to treat the snake bite Harry got from Nagini in Bathilda’s house.
            – Janus Bahs Jacquet
            yesterday






          • 1




            You can add one space character in front of the first > to bring the quote block into the list.
            – unor
            yesterday












          • @unor Nice- next time you can edit the answer directly :)
            – Filip Kočica
            yesterday



















          7















          Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying?




          Can she even do it?



          First she is not a healer and only thing she ever used in film to heal was Dittany but ti was only used for a hand wound and not as fatal wound as chest wound of Dobby.



          Dittany's use is also covered in similar question from Science Fiction and Fantasy :



          Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?



          So here were are expecting a lot from Hermione like Harry did.






          share|improve this answer































            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes








            2 Answers
            2






            active

            oldest

            votes









            active

            oldest

            votes






            active

            oldest

            votes









            24














            Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby




            • Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn't Madam Pomfrey. Similarly, she was not able to save Snape in deathly hallows part 2.


            • Hermione was definitely in shock, because she was tortured by Bellatrix several minutes ago - she needed help herself first



            • Dittany heals a lot of things, but a knife through the chest may not be one of them. Also as Hermione mentions, it may the injuries make even worse




              " 'It's all I feel safe doing,' said Hermione shakily. 'There are
              spells that would put him completely right, but I daren't try in case
              I do them wrong and cause more damage.... He's lost so much blood
              already...."




            • Most important - she was not there while Dobby was dying at the beach, they went to house together with Ron (she is present just in the film)


            • Here is the list of all known healing spells. None of them can probably heal such a fatal injury Dobby has suffered.


            • In the book Hermione stuffed the beaded bag in her sock to save it. In the film, the snatchers got the beaded bag.





            Further reading




            • Science Fiction and Fantasy: Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?

            • Quora: Why didn't Hermione heal Dobby in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1?






            share|improve this answer























            • I always figured Dittany was just for Apparition
              – Azor Ahai
              2 days ago










            • @AzorAhai > There may be a certain amount of scarring, but if you take dittany immediately we might avoid even that.. Severus Snape to Draco Malfoy after Sectumsempra, HBP.
              – Bob
              yesterday












            • @AzorAhai Hermione also used it to treat the burns the trio got while breaking into Gringotts, as well as to treat the snake bite Harry got from Nagini in Bathilda’s house.
              – Janus Bahs Jacquet
              yesterday






            • 1




              You can add one space character in front of the first > to bring the quote block into the list.
              – unor
              yesterday












            • @unor Nice- next time you can edit the answer directly :)
              – Filip Kočica
              yesterday
















            24














            Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby




            • Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn't Madam Pomfrey. Similarly, she was not able to save Snape in deathly hallows part 2.


            • Hermione was definitely in shock, because she was tortured by Bellatrix several minutes ago - she needed help herself first



            • Dittany heals a lot of things, but a knife through the chest may not be one of them. Also as Hermione mentions, it may the injuries make even worse




              " 'It's all I feel safe doing,' said Hermione shakily. 'There are
              spells that would put him completely right, but I daren't try in case
              I do them wrong and cause more damage.... He's lost so much blood
              already...."




            • Most important - she was not there while Dobby was dying at the beach, they went to house together with Ron (she is present just in the film)


            • Here is the list of all known healing spells. None of them can probably heal such a fatal injury Dobby has suffered.


            • In the book Hermione stuffed the beaded bag in her sock to save it. In the film, the snatchers got the beaded bag.





            Further reading




            • Science Fiction and Fantasy: Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?

            • Quora: Why didn't Hermione heal Dobby in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1?






            share|improve this answer























            • I always figured Dittany was just for Apparition
              – Azor Ahai
              2 days ago










            • @AzorAhai > There may be a certain amount of scarring, but if you take dittany immediately we might avoid even that.. Severus Snape to Draco Malfoy after Sectumsempra, HBP.
              – Bob
              yesterday












            • @AzorAhai Hermione also used it to treat the burns the trio got while breaking into Gringotts, as well as to treat the snake bite Harry got from Nagini in Bathilda’s house.
              – Janus Bahs Jacquet
              yesterday






            • 1




              You can add one space character in front of the first > to bring the quote block into the list.
              – unor
              yesterday












            • @unor Nice- next time you can edit the answer directly :)
              – Filip Kočica
              yesterday














            24












            24








            24






            Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby




            • Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn't Madam Pomfrey. Similarly, she was not able to save Snape in deathly hallows part 2.


            • Hermione was definitely in shock, because she was tortured by Bellatrix several minutes ago - she needed help herself first



            • Dittany heals a lot of things, but a knife through the chest may not be one of them. Also as Hermione mentions, it may the injuries make even worse




              " 'It's all I feel safe doing,' said Hermione shakily. 'There are
              spells that would put him completely right, but I daren't try in case
              I do them wrong and cause more damage.... He's lost so much blood
              already...."




            • Most important - she was not there while Dobby was dying at the beach, they went to house together with Ron (she is present just in the film)


            • Here is the list of all known healing spells. None of them can probably heal such a fatal injury Dobby has suffered.


            • In the book Hermione stuffed the beaded bag in her sock to save it. In the film, the snatchers got the beaded bag.





            Further reading




            • Science Fiction and Fantasy: Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?

            • Quora: Why didn't Hermione heal Dobby in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1?






            share|improve this answer














            Several things explaining why she wasn't able to heal Dobby




            • Even though she had a general knowledge of various spells, she was not trained for healing - even in the books she mentions she never attempted to further her knowledge of healing wounds. Hermione knows how to use healing potions, but she isn't Madam Pomfrey. Similarly, she was not able to save Snape in deathly hallows part 2.


            • Hermione was definitely in shock, because she was tortured by Bellatrix several minutes ago - she needed help herself first



            • Dittany heals a lot of things, but a knife through the chest may not be one of them. Also as Hermione mentions, it may the injuries make even worse




              " 'It's all I feel safe doing,' said Hermione shakily. 'There are
              spells that would put him completely right, but I daren't try in case
              I do them wrong and cause more damage.... He's lost so much blood
              already...."




            • Most important - she was not there while Dobby was dying at the beach, they went to house together with Ron (she is present just in the film)


            • Here is the list of all known healing spells. None of them can probably heal such a fatal injury Dobby has suffered.


            • In the book Hermione stuffed the beaded bag in her sock to save it. In the film, the snatchers got the beaded bag.





            Further reading




            • Science Fiction and Fantasy: Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?

            • Quora: Why didn't Hermione heal Dobby in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part 1?







            share|improve this answer














            share|improve this answer



            share|improve this answer








            edited 23 hours ago









            Nog Shine

            6,78423463




            6,78423463










            answered 2 days ago









            Filip Kočica

            65812




            65812












            • I always figured Dittany was just for Apparition
              – Azor Ahai
              2 days ago










            • @AzorAhai > There may be a certain amount of scarring, but if you take dittany immediately we might avoid even that.. Severus Snape to Draco Malfoy after Sectumsempra, HBP.
              – Bob
              yesterday












            • @AzorAhai Hermione also used it to treat the burns the trio got while breaking into Gringotts, as well as to treat the snake bite Harry got from Nagini in Bathilda’s house.
              – Janus Bahs Jacquet
              yesterday






            • 1




              You can add one space character in front of the first > to bring the quote block into the list.
              – unor
              yesterday












            • @unor Nice- next time you can edit the answer directly :)
              – Filip Kočica
              yesterday


















            • I always figured Dittany was just for Apparition
              – Azor Ahai
              2 days ago










            • @AzorAhai > There may be a certain amount of scarring, but if you take dittany immediately we might avoid even that.. Severus Snape to Draco Malfoy after Sectumsempra, HBP.
              – Bob
              yesterday












            • @AzorAhai Hermione also used it to treat the burns the trio got while breaking into Gringotts, as well as to treat the snake bite Harry got from Nagini in Bathilda’s house.
              – Janus Bahs Jacquet
              yesterday






            • 1




              You can add one space character in front of the first > to bring the quote block into the list.
              – unor
              yesterday












            • @unor Nice- next time you can edit the answer directly :)
              – Filip Kočica
              yesterday
















            I always figured Dittany was just for Apparition
            – Azor Ahai
            2 days ago




            I always figured Dittany was just for Apparition
            – Azor Ahai
            2 days ago












            @AzorAhai > There may be a certain amount of scarring, but if you take dittany immediately we might avoid even that.. Severus Snape to Draco Malfoy after Sectumsempra, HBP.
            – Bob
            yesterday






            @AzorAhai > There may be a certain amount of scarring, but if you take dittany immediately we might avoid even that.. Severus Snape to Draco Malfoy after Sectumsempra, HBP.
            – Bob
            yesterday














            @AzorAhai Hermione also used it to treat the burns the trio got while breaking into Gringotts, as well as to treat the snake bite Harry got from Nagini in Bathilda’s house.
            – Janus Bahs Jacquet
            yesterday




            @AzorAhai Hermione also used it to treat the burns the trio got while breaking into Gringotts, as well as to treat the snake bite Harry got from Nagini in Bathilda’s house.
            – Janus Bahs Jacquet
            yesterday




            1




            1




            You can add one space character in front of the first > to bring the quote block into the list.
            – unor
            yesterday






            You can add one space character in front of the first > to bring the quote block into the list.
            – unor
            yesterday














            @unor Nice- next time you can edit the answer directly :)
            – Filip Kočica
            yesterday




            @unor Nice- next time you can edit the answer directly :)
            – Filip Kočica
            yesterday











            7















            Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying?




            Can she even do it?



            First she is not a healer and only thing she ever used in film to heal was Dittany but ti was only used for a hand wound and not as fatal wound as chest wound of Dobby.



            Dittany's use is also covered in similar question from Science Fiction and Fantasy :



            Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?



            So here were are expecting a lot from Hermione like Harry did.






            share|improve this answer




























              7















              Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying?




              Can she even do it?



              First she is not a healer and only thing she ever used in film to heal was Dittany but ti was only used for a hand wound and not as fatal wound as chest wound of Dobby.



              Dittany's use is also covered in similar question from Science Fiction and Fantasy :



              Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?



              So here were are expecting a lot from Hermione like Harry did.






              share|improve this answer


























                7












                7








                7







                Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying?




                Can she even do it?



                First she is not a healer and only thing she ever used in film to heal was Dittany but ti was only used for a hand wound and not as fatal wound as chest wound of Dobby.



                Dittany's use is also covered in similar question from Science Fiction and Fantasy :



                Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?



                So here were are expecting a lot from Hermione like Harry did.






                share|improve this answer















                Why didn't Hermione do anything while Dobby was dying?




                Can she even do it?



                First she is not a healer and only thing she ever used in film to heal was Dittany but ti was only used for a hand wound and not as fatal wound as chest wound of Dobby.



                Dittany's use is also covered in similar question from Science Fiction and Fantasy :



                Why didn't Hermione use her Dittany on Dobby when he was dying?



                So here were are expecting a lot from Hermione like Harry did.







                share|improve this answer














                share|improve this answer



                share|improve this answer








                edited 2 days ago

























                answered 2 days ago









                Ankit Sharma

                72.2k61378583




                72.2k61378583















                    Popular posts from this blog

                    If I really need a card on my start hand, how many mulligans make sense? [duplicate]

                    Alcedinidae

                    Can an atomic nucleus contain both particles and antiparticles? [duplicate]