Was Rowling inspired by the railway station scene in Prince Caspian?












5















I was rereading Prince Caspian and noticed that in the start of the story they're in




an empty, sleepy country station, and there was hardly anyone on the platform but themselves




and then they're magically pulled away to Narnia from there (and at the end, they end up back on the platform).



Is it possible Rowling was inspired by this to have wizards and witches head to Hogwarts from a railway platform?










share|improve this question

























  • Related: Did J. K. Rowling base platform 9 3/4 on the Gump?

    – Mithrandir
    7 hours ago
















5















I was rereading Prince Caspian and noticed that in the start of the story they're in




an empty, sleepy country station, and there was hardly anyone on the platform but themselves




and then they're magically pulled away to Narnia from there (and at the end, they end up back on the platform).



Is it possible Rowling was inspired by this to have wizards and witches head to Hogwarts from a railway platform?










share|improve this question

























  • Related: Did J. K. Rowling base platform 9 3/4 on the Gump?

    – Mithrandir
    7 hours ago














5












5








5








I was rereading Prince Caspian and noticed that in the start of the story they're in




an empty, sleepy country station, and there was hardly anyone on the platform but themselves




and then they're magically pulled away to Narnia from there (and at the end, they end up back on the platform).



Is it possible Rowling was inspired by this to have wizards and witches head to Hogwarts from a railway platform?










share|improve this question
















I was rereading Prince Caspian and noticed that in the start of the story they're in




an empty, sleepy country station, and there was hardly anyone on the platform but themselves




and then they're magically pulled away to Narnia from there (and at the end, they end up back on the platform).



Is it possible Rowling was inspired by this to have wizards and witches head to Hogwarts from a railway platform?







inspiration c-s-lewis the-chronicles-of-narnia j-k-rowling harry-potter






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited 7 hours ago









Mithrandir

8,59564490




8,59564490










asked 7 hours ago









heatherheather

2,786732




2,786732













  • Related: Did J. K. Rowling base platform 9 3/4 on the Gump?

    – Mithrandir
    7 hours ago



















  • Related: Did J. K. Rowling base platform 9 3/4 on the Gump?

    – Mithrandir
    7 hours ago

















Related: Did J. K. Rowling base platform 9 3/4 on the Gump?

– Mithrandir
7 hours ago





Related: Did J. K. Rowling base platform 9 3/4 on the Gump?

– Mithrandir
7 hours ago










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















5














Oddly enough, Rowling has cited The Chronicles of Narnia as an inspiration for her King's Cross entryway to the world of magic, but not the part you're thinking of!




I found myself thinking about the wardrobe route to Narnia when Harry is told he has to hurl himself at a barrier in Kings Cross Station - it dissolves and he's on platform Nine and Three-Quarters, and there's the train for Hogwarts.



Source: an interview she did for the Sydney Morning Herald in 2001.




She's also claimed, in a piece of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore, that she chose King's Cross as the point of entry for getting to Hogwarts because of its personal significance to her:




King’s Cross, which is one of London’s main railway stations, has a very personal significance for me, because my parents met on a train to Scotland which departed from King’s Cross station. For this reason, and because it has such an evocative and symbolic name, and because it is actually the right station to leave from if you were heading to Caledonia, I never knew the slightest indecision about the location of the portal that would take Harry to Hogwarts, or the means of transport that would take him there.




(It's possible that both of these are true - she could have been inspired by her personal/family history to use King's Cross, and inspired by Narnia to have Harry hurl himself at a wall - but if we're to take them as conflicting pieces of evidence, I'd much rather rely on the earlier statement from an interview than the later one from Pottermore. I'm frankly doubtful that all of those pieces of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore were really written by her, and even if so, she seems to be putting less care into her new additions to the Potterverse lore these days than she did back when she was writing the books. It's worth noting that she misremembered King's Cross when writing the platform scene.)






share|improve this answer



















  • 2





    That's really peculiar - I suppose I can sort of see the resemblance, but the whole being-tugged-from-a-railway-platform bit strikes me as far more similar. Anyway, thanks for the answer. I'd be curious if anymore evidence can be turned up (I agree that Pottermore can be rather...doubtful at times.)

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • @heather Apart from the location being a railway platform, I can't see much similarity between the Prince Caspian summoning and Platform 9.75. Harry isn't tugged from a railway platform; he wants to go there. The Narnia transition isn't physical like hitting the wall at King's Cross. Small empty countryside station vs big London terminus. (I agree the wardrobe isn't very similar either ...)

    – Rand al'Thor
    6 hours ago











  • True, but 'entering magical world from a railway platform' describes both cases. Whereas the wardrobe and King's Cross can only both be described as 'entering a magical world' - though I do agree the calling vs. wanting is an interesting point.

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • maybe worth mentioning: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_of_Platform_13

    – Niffler
    5 hours ago











Your Answer








StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "668"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});


}
});














draft saved

draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fliterature.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f9413%2fwas-rowling-inspired-by-the-railway-station-scene-in-prince-caspian%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









5














Oddly enough, Rowling has cited The Chronicles of Narnia as an inspiration for her King's Cross entryway to the world of magic, but not the part you're thinking of!




I found myself thinking about the wardrobe route to Narnia when Harry is told he has to hurl himself at a barrier in Kings Cross Station - it dissolves and he's on platform Nine and Three-Quarters, and there's the train for Hogwarts.



Source: an interview she did for the Sydney Morning Herald in 2001.




She's also claimed, in a piece of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore, that she chose King's Cross as the point of entry for getting to Hogwarts because of its personal significance to her:




King’s Cross, which is one of London’s main railway stations, has a very personal significance for me, because my parents met on a train to Scotland which departed from King’s Cross station. For this reason, and because it has such an evocative and symbolic name, and because it is actually the right station to leave from if you were heading to Caledonia, I never knew the slightest indecision about the location of the portal that would take Harry to Hogwarts, or the means of transport that would take him there.




(It's possible that both of these are true - she could have been inspired by her personal/family history to use King's Cross, and inspired by Narnia to have Harry hurl himself at a wall - but if we're to take them as conflicting pieces of evidence, I'd much rather rely on the earlier statement from an interview than the later one from Pottermore. I'm frankly doubtful that all of those pieces of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore were really written by her, and even if so, she seems to be putting less care into her new additions to the Potterverse lore these days than she did back when she was writing the books. It's worth noting that she misremembered King's Cross when writing the platform scene.)






share|improve this answer



















  • 2





    That's really peculiar - I suppose I can sort of see the resemblance, but the whole being-tugged-from-a-railway-platform bit strikes me as far more similar. Anyway, thanks for the answer. I'd be curious if anymore evidence can be turned up (I agree that Pottermore can be rather...doubtful at times.)

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • @heather Apart from the location being a railway platform, I can't see much similarity between the Prince Caspian summoning and Platform 9.75. Harry isn't tugged from a railway platform; he wants to go there. The Narnia transition isn't physical like hitting the wall at King's Cross. Small empty countryside station vs big London terminus. (I agree the wardrobe isn't very similar either ...)

    – Rand al'Thor
    6 hours ago











  • True, but 'entering magical world from a railway platform' describes both cases. Whereas the wardrobe and King's Cross can only both be described as 'entering a magical world' - though I do agree the calling vs. wanting is an interesting point.

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • maybe worth mentioning: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_of_Platform_13

    – Niffler
    5 hours ago
















5














Oddly enough, Rowling has cited The Chronicles of Narnia as an inspiration for her King's Cross entryway to the world of magic, but not the part you're thinking of!




I found myself thinking about the wardrobe route to Narnia when Harry is told he has to hurl himself at a barrier in Kings Cross Station - it dissolves and he's on platform Nine and Three-Quarters, and there's the train for Hogwarts.



Source: an interview she did for the Sydney Morning Herald in 2001.




She's also claimed, in a piece of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore, that she chose King's Cross as the point of entry for getting to Hogwarts because of its personal significance to her:




King’s Cross, which is one of London’s main railway stations, has a very personal significance for me, because my parents met on a train to Scotland which departed from King’s Cross station. For this reason, and because it has such an evocative and symbolic name, and because it is actually the right station to leave from if you were heading to Caledonia, I never knew the slightest indecision about the location of the portal that would take Harry to Hogwarts, or the means of transport that would take him there.




(It's possible that both of these are true - she could have been inspired by her personal/family history to use King's Cross, and inspired by Narnia to have Harry hurl himself at a wall - but if we're to take them as conflicting pieces of evidence, I'd much rather rely on the earlier statement from an interview than the later one from Pottermore. I'm frankly doubtful that all of those pieces of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore were really written by her, and even if so, she seems to be putting less care into her new additions to the Potterverse lore these days than she did back when she was writing the books. It's worth noting that she misremembered King's Cross when writing the platform scene.)






share|improve this answer



















  • 2





    That's really peculiar - I suppose I can sort of see the resemblance, but the whole being-tugged-from-a-railway-platform bit strikes me as far more similar. Anyway, thanks for the answer. I'd be curious if anymore evidence can be turned up (I agree that Pottermore can be rather...doubtful at times.)

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • @heather Apart from the location being a railway platform, I can't see much similarity between the Prince Caspian summoning and Platform 9.75. Harry isn't tugged from a railway platform; he wants to go there. The Narnia transition isn't physical like hitting the wall at King's Cross. Small empty countryside station vs big London terminus. (I agree the wardrobe isn't very similar either ...)

    – Rand al'Thor
    6 hours ago











  • True, but 'entering magical world from a railway platform' describes both cases. Whereas the wardrobe and King's Cross can only both be described as 'entering a magical world' - though I do agree the calling vs. wanting is an interesting point.

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • maybe worth mentioning: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_of_Platform_13

    – Niffler
    5 hours ago














5












5








5







Oddly enough, Rowling has cited The Chronicles of Narnia as an inspiration for her King's Cross entryway to the world of magic, but not the part you're thinking of!




I found myself thinking about the wardrobe route to Narnia when Harry is told he has to hurl himself at a barrier in Kings Cross Station - it dissolves and he's on platform Nine and Three-Quarters, and there's the train for Hogwarts.



Source: an interview she did for the Sydney Morning Herald in 2001.




She's also claimed, in a piece of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore, that she chose King's Cross as the point of entry for getting to Hogwarts because of its personal significance to her:




King’s Cross, which is one of London’s main railway stations, has a very personal significance for me, because my parents met on a train to Scotland which departed from King’s Cross station. For this reason, and because it has such an evocative and symbolic name, and because it is actually the right station to leave from if you were heading to Caledonia, I never knew the slightest indecision about the location of the portal that would take Harry to Hogwarts, or the means of transport that would take him there.




(It's possible that both of these are true - she could have been inspired by her personal/family history to use King's Cross, and inspired by Narnia to have Harry hurl himself at a wall - but if we're to take them as conflicting pieces of evidence, I'd much rather rely on the earlier statement from an interview than the later one from Pottermore. I'm frankly doubtful that all of those pieces of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore were really written by her, and even if so, she seems to be putting less care into her new additions to the Potterverse lore these days than she did back when she was writing the books. It's worth noting that she misremembered King's Cross when writing the platform scene.)






share|improve this answer













Oddly enough, Rowling has cited The Chronicles of Narnia as an inspiration for her King's Cross entryway to the world of magic, but not the part you're thinking of!




I found myself thinking about the wardrobe route to Narnia when Harry is told he has to hurl himself at a barrier in Kings Cross Station - it dissolves and he's on platform Nine and Three-Quarters, and there's the train for Hogwarts.



Source: an interview she did for the Sydney Morning Herald in 2001.




She's also claimed, in a piece of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore, that she chose King's Cross as the point of entry for getting to Hogwarts because of its personal significance to her:




King’s Cross, which is one of London’s main railway stations, has a very personal significance for me, because my parents met on a train to Scotland which departed from King’s Cross station. For this reason, and because it has such an evocative and symbolic name, and because it is actually the right station to leave from if you were heading to Caledonia, I never knew the slightest indecision about the location of the portal that would take Harry to Hogwarts, or the means of transport that would take him there.




(It's possible that both of these are true - she could have been inspired by her personal/family history to use King's Cross, and inspired by Narnia to have Harry hurl himself at a wall - but if we're to take them as conflicting pieces of evidence, I'd much rather rely on the earlier statement from an interview than the later one from Pottermore. I'm frankly doubtful that all of those pieces of "writing by J. K. Rowling" on Pottermore were really written by her, and even if so, she seems to be putting less care into her new additions to the Potterverse lore these days than she did back when she was writing the books. It's worth noting that she misremembered King's Cross when writing the platform scene.)







share|improve this answer












share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer










answered 6 hours ago









Rand al'ThorRand al'Thor

25.4k878204




25.4k878204








  • 2





    That's really peculiar - I suppose I can sort of see the resemblance, but the whole being-tugged-from-a-railway-platform bit strikes me as far more similar. Anyway, thanks for the answer. I'd be curious if anymore evidence can be turned up (I agree that Pottermore can be rather...doubtful at times.)

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • @heather Apart from the location being a railway platform, I can't see much similarity between the Prince Caspian summoning and Platform 9.75. Harry isn't tugged from a railway platform; he wants to go there. The Narnia transition isn't physical like hitting the wall at King's Cross. Small empty countryside station vs big London terminus. (I agree the wardrobe isn't very similar either ...)

    – Rand al'Thor
    6 hours ago











  • True, but 'entering magical world from a railway platform' describes both cases. Whereas the wardrobe and King's Cross can only both be described as 'entering a magical world' - though I do agree the calling vs. wanting is an interesting point.

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • maybe worth mentioning: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_of_Platform_13

    – Niffler
    5 hours ago














  • 2





    That's really peculiar - I suppose I can sort of see the resemblance, but the whole being-tugged-from-a-railway-platform bit strikes me as far more similar. Anyway, thanks for the answer. I'd be curious if anymore evidence can be turned up (I agree that Pottermore can be rather...doubtful at times.)

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • @heather Apart from the location being a railway platform, I can't see much similarity between the Prince Caspian summoning and Platform 9.75. Harry isn't tugged from a railway platform; he wants to go there. The Narnia transition isn't physical like hitting the wall at King's Cross. Small empty countryside station vs big London terminus. (I agree the wardrobe isn't very similar either ...)

    – Rand al'Thor
    6 hours ago











  • True, but 'entering magical world from a railway platform' describes both cases. Whereas the wardrobe and King's Cross can only both be described as 'entering a magical world' - though I do agree the calling vs. wanting is an interesting point.

    – heather
    6 hours ago











  • maybe worth mentioning: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_of_Platform_13

    – Niffler
    5 hours ago








2




2





That's really peculiar - I suppose I can sort of see the resemblance, but the whole being-tugged-from-a-railway-platform bit strikes me as far more similar. Anyway, thanks for the answer. I'd be curious if anymore evidence can be turned up (I agree that Pottermore can be rather...doubtful at times.)

– heather
6 hours ago





That's really peculiar - I suppose I can sort of see the resemblance, but the whole being-tugged-from-a-railway-platform bit strikes me as far more similar. Anyway, thanks for the answer. I'd be curious if anymore evidence can be turned up (I agree that Pottermore can be rather...doubtful at times.)

– heather
6 hours ago













@heather Apart from the location being a railway platform, I can't see much similarity between the Prince Caspian summoning and Platform 9.75. Harry isn't tugged from a railway platform; he wants to go there. The Narnia transition isn't physical like hitting the wall at King's Cross. Small empty countryside station vs big London terminus. (I agree the wardrobe isn't very similar either ...)

– Rand al'Thor
6 hours ago





@heather Apart from the location being a railway platform, I can't see much similarity between the Prince Caspian summoning and Platform 9.75. Harry isn't tugged from a railway platform; he wants to go there. The Narnia transition isn't physical like hitting the wall at King's Cross. Small empty countryside station vs big London terminus. (I agree the wardrobe isn't very similar either ...)

– Rand al'Thor
6 hours ago













True, but 'entering magical world from a railway platform' describes both cases. Whereas the wardrobe and King's Cross can only both be described as 'entering a magical world' - though I do agree the calling vs. wanting is an interesting point.

– heather
6 hours ago





True, but 'entering magical world from a railway platform' describes both cases. Whereas the wardrobe and King's Cross can only both be described as 'entering a magical world' - though I do agree the calling vs. wanting is an interesting point.

– heather
6 hours ago













maybe worth mentioning: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_of_Platform_13

– Niffler
5 hours ago





maybe worth mentioning: en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Secret_of_Platform_13

– Niffler
5 hours ago


















draft saved

draft discarded




















































Thanks for contributing an answer to Literature Stack Exchange!


  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid



  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fliterature.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f9413%2fwas-rowling-inspired-by-the-railway-station-scene-in-prince-caspian%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

"Incorrect syntax near the keyword 'ON'. (on update cascade, on delete cascade,)

Alcedinidae

RAC Tourist Trophy