Best way to abandon a bag in Hong Kong airport?
An odd question, I know.
I'm expecting to arrive with a full-size carry-on, containing some stuff I brought on the flight but don't want to carry any further, some stuff I'll transfer into my main baggage between collecting it from the belt and dropping it off with WFS for onward delivery, and some stuff I'll carry with me in a much smaller bag waiting in my main suitcase. I don't really want to elaborate on why this is the case as it will distract from the main question - nothing nefarious is going on, I just have a slightly complex itinerary and don't want to lug any more than I need to at any point.
I'm then left with an unwanted carry-on bag containing a few innocuous cheap unwanted possessions (nothing unpleasant, not even any dirty clothes). I'll deliberately use an old and slightly broken (torn handle) bag that I've already replaced and is currently just cluttering up my house. If it were a soft bag I'd roll it up and stuff it in a litter-bin, but it's a somewhat rigid two-wheel trolley bag that won't fit in any normal bin.
What I obviously don't want to do is leave a bag just lying around in the airport and trigger a security scare. My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt, where it can go round and round until eventually the baggage handlers recover it. There will be no obvious means of identification on it, and I will leave a note inside in English and Cantonese saying that I don't want it any more, to save them wasting any effort trying to track down an owner. Then they will presumably just dispose of it by whatever means they have for unidentifiable lost possessions.
Anyone have any better ideas? Maybe this is all needless subterfuge and there's actually a handy bulk rubbish container tucked away somewhere that I could chuck it into? In or near the baggage reclaim, ideally.
luggage airports hong-kong
New contributor
|
show 9 more comments
An odd question, I know.
I'm expecting to arrive with a full-size carry-on, containing some stuff I brought on the flight but don't want to carry any further, some stuff I'll transfer into my main baggage between collecting it from the belt and dropping it off with WFS for onward delivery, and some stuff I'll carry with me in a much smaller bag waiting in my main suitcase. I don't really want to elaborate on why this is the case as it will distract from the main question - nothing nefarious is going on, I just have a slightly complex itinerary and don't want to lug any more than I need to at any point.
I'm then left with an unwanted carry-on bag containing a few innocuous cheap unwanted possessions (nothing unpleasant, not even any dirty clothes). I'll deliberately use an old and slightly broken (torn handle) bag that I've already replaced and is currently just cluttering up my house. If it were a soft bag I'd roll it up and stuff it in a litter-bin, but it's a somewhat rigid two-wheel trolley bag that won't fit in any normal bin.
What I obviously don't want to do is leave a bag just lying around in the airport and trigger a security scare. My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt, where it can go round and round until eventually the baggage handlers recover it. There will be no obvious means of identification on it, and I will leave a note inside in English and Cantonese saying that I don't want it any more, to save them wasting any effort trying to track down an owner. Then they will presumably just dispose of it by whatever means they have for unidentifiable lost possessions.
Anyone have any better ideas? Maybe this is all needless subterfuge and there's actually a handy bulk rubbish container tucked away somewhere that I could chuck it into? In or near the baggage reclaim, ideally.
luggage airports hong-kong
New contributor
25
Wouldn't they treat a bag on the carousel without a tag sending it to that airport just like a bag left lying around? The undramatic lost luggage processing is for a bag that has been through security at the airport it came from.
– Patricia Shanahan
yesterday
20
How will you have "main baggage between collecting it from the belt" if you're not checking anything? Consider how this'll look to anyone watching - you're suggesting taking a bag off the baggage belt, moving items between bags, and then putting a bag back on the belt. This will look like you are stealing the contents of the bag to anyone watching...
– Doc
yesterday
6
Instead of a bag, consider using a simple cardboard box.
– Antzi
23 hours ago
34
"My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt etc ..". That is utterly ridiculous. Are you joking?! Just leave it OPEN AND EMPTY near a trash can - simple.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@Guest24601 I wouldn't recommend performing surgery on a suitcase and then stuffing it into a bin either. Again, that looks like something that someone up to no good would do. You mention that the bag is not in perfect condition, I doubt you'd be the first person to ask about disposing such an item.
– Richard
15 hours ago
|
show 9 more comments
An odd question, I know.
I'm expecting to arrive with a full-size carry-on, containing some stuff I brought on the flight but don't want to carry any further, some stuff I'll transfer into my main baggage between collecting it from the belt and dropping it off with WFS for onward delivery, and some stuff I'll carry with me in a much smaller bag waiting in my main suitcase. I don't really want to elaborate on why this is the case as it will distract from the main question - nothing nefarious is going on, I just have a slightly complex itinerary and don't want to lug any more than I need to at any point.
I'm then left with an unwanted carry-on bag containing a few innocuous cheap unwanted possessions (nothing unpleasant, not even any dirty clothes). I'll deliberately use an old and slightly broken (torn handle) bag that I've already replaced and is currently just cluttering up my house. If it were a soft bag I'd roll it up and stuff it in a litter-bin, but it's a somewhat rigid two-wheel trolley bag that won't fit in any normal bin.
What I obviously don't want to do is leave a bag just lying around in the airport and trigger a security scare. My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt, where it can go round and round until eventually the baggage handlers recover it. There will be no obvious means of identification on it, and I will leave a note inside in English and Cantonese saying that I don't want it any more, to save them wasting any effort trying to track down an owner. Then they will presumably just dispose of it by whatever means they have for unidentifiable lost possessions.
Anyone have any better ideas? Maybe this is all needless subterfuge and there's actually a handy bulk rubbish container tucked away somewhere that I could chuck it into? In or near the baggage reclaim, ideally.
luggage airports hong-kong
New contributor
An odd question, I know.
I'm expecting to arrive with a full-size carry-on, containing some stuff I brought on the flight but don't want to carry any further, some stuff I'll transfer into my main baggage between collecting it from the belt and dropping it off with WFS for onward delivery, and some stuff I'll carry with me in a much smaller bag waiting in my main suitcase. I don't really want to elaborate on why this is the case as it will distract from the main question - nothing nefarious is going on, I just have a slightly complex itinerary and don't want to lug any more than I need to at any point.
I'm then left with an unwanted carry-on bag containing a few innocuous cheap unwanted possessions (nothing unpleasant, not even any dirty clothes). I'll deliberately use an old and slightly broken (torn handle) bag that I've already replaced and is currently just cluttering up my house. If it were a soft bag I'd roll it up and stuff it in a litter-bin, but it's a somewhat rigid two-wheel trolley bag that won't fit in any normal bin.
What I obviously don't want to do is leave a bag just lying around in the airport and trigger a security scare. My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt, where it can go round and round until eventually the baggage handlers recover it. There will be no obvious means of identification on it, and I will leave a note inside in English and Cantonese saying that I don't want it any more, to save them wasting any effort trying to track down an owner. Then they will presumably just dispose of it by whatever means they have for unidentifiable lost possessions.
Anyone have any better ideas? Maybe this is all needless subterfuge and there's actually a handy bulk rubbish container tucked away somewhere that I could chuck it into? In or near the baggage reclaim, ideally.
luggage airports hong-kong
luggage airports hong-kong
New contributor
New contributor
New contributor
asked yesterday
Guest24601Guest24601
219124
219124
New contributor
New contributor
25
Wouldn't they treat a bag on the carousel without a tag sending it to that airport just like a bag left lying around? The undramatic lost luggage processing is for a bag that has been through security at the airport it came from.
– Patricia Shanahan
yesterday
20
How will you have "main baggage between collecting it from the belt" if you're not checking anything? Consider how this'll look to anyone watching - you're suggesting taking a bag off the baggage belt, moving items between bags, and then putting a bag back on the belt. This will look like you are stealing the contents of the bag to anyone watching...
– Doc
yesterday
6
Instead of a bag, consider using a simple cardboard box.
– Antzi
23 hours ago
34
"My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt etc ..". That is utterly ridiculous. Are you joking?! Just leave it OPEN AND EMPTY near a trash can - simple.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@Guest24601 I wouldn't recommend performing surgery on a suitcase and then stuffing it into a bin either. Again, that looks like something that someone up to no good would do. You mention that the bag is not in perfect condition, I doubt you'd be the first person to ask about disposing such an item.
– Richard
15 hours ago
|
show 9 more comments
25
Wouldn't they treat a bag on the carousel without a tag sending it to that airport just like a bag left lying around? The undramatic lost luggage processing is for a bag that has been through security at the airport it came from.
– Patricia Shanahan
yesterday
20
How will you have "main baggage between collecting it from the belt" if you're not checking anything? Consider how this'll look to anyone watching - you're suggesting taking a bag off the baggage belt, moving items between bags, and then putting a bag back on the belt. This will look like you are stealing the contents of the bag to anyone watching...
– Doc
yesterday
6
Instead of a bag, consider using a simple cardboard box.
– Antzi
23 hours ago
34
"My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt etc ..". That is utterly ridiculous. Are you joking?! Just leave it OPEN AND EMPTY near a trash can - simple.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@Guest24601 I wouldn't recommend performing surgery on a suitcase and then stuffing it into a bin either. Again, that looks like something that someone up to no good would do. You mention that the bag is not in perfect condition, I doubt you'd be the first person to ask about disposing such an item.
– Richard
15 hours ago
25
25
Wouldn't they treat a bag on the carousel without a tag sending it to that airport just like a bag left lying around? The undramatic lost luggage processing is for a bag that has been through security at the airport it came from.
– Patricia Shanahan
yesterday
Wouldn't they treat a bag on the carousel without a tag sending it to that airport just like a bag left lying around? The undramatic lost luggage processing is for a bag that has been through security at the airport it came from.
– Patricia Shanahan
yesterday
20
20
How will you have "main baggage between collecting it from the belt" if you're not checking anything? Consider how this'll look to anyone watching - you're suggesting taking a bag off the baggage belt, moving items between bags, and then putting a bag back on the belt. This will look like you are stealing the contents of the bag to anyone watching...
– Doc
yesterday
How will you have "main baggage between collecting it from the belt" if you're not checking anything? Consider how this'll look to anyone watching - you're suggesting taking a bag off the baggage belt, moving items between bags, and then putting a bag back on the belt. This will look like you are stealing the contents of the bag to anyone watching...
– Doc
yesterday
6
6
Instead of a bag, consider using a simple cardboard box.
– Antzi
23 hours ago
Instead of a bag, consider using a simple cardboard box.
– Antzi
23 hours ago
34
34
"My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt etc ..". That is utterly ridiculous. Are you joking?! Just leave it OPEN AND EMPTY near a trash can - simple.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
"My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt etc ..". That is utterly ridiculous. Are you joking?! Just leave it OPEN AND EMPTY near a trash can - simple.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
3
@Guest24601 I wouldn't recommend performing surgery on a suitcase and then stuffing it into a bin either. Again, that looks like something that someone up to no good would do. You mention that the bag is not in perfect condition, I doubt you'd be the first person to ask about disposing such an item.
– Richard
15 hours ago
@Guest24601 I wouldn't recommend performing surgery on a suitcase and then stuffing it into a bin either. Again, that looks like something that someone up to no good would do. You mention that the bag is not in perfect condition, I doubt you'd be the first person to ask about disposing such an item.
– Richard
15 hours ago
|
show 9 more comments
9 Answers
9
active
oldest
votes
Ask at the airport information desk, lost property, or a luggage shop (thanks @Fattie). They most likely know some way of ensuring the contents gets given to a charity or at least recycled properly.
Subterfuge will at the very least create overhead for the airport personnel, who will have to either destroy the contents safely or hold on to it for a long time before disposing of it. And you really don't want to have to explain yourself to airport security if this spiel is noticed.
21
I think this is the best answer. Why contrive a strange plan to shed the bag surreptitiously instead of walking to a desk (or even to a security officer) and ask "Sorry, but I want to get rid of that bag, where could I drop it off?" An airport has tons of waste to dispose every day, they would know where to put it.
– Dubu
20 hours ago
2
This is the "you-beat-me-to-it" answer. OP, simply explain to security what you explained to us and follow their instructions with them. With.
– Mikey
17 hours ago
10
Disposing of a broken or un-needed luggage at an airport is totally straightforward. Folks commonly buy new luggage at the luggage shops, and dispose of the old one. Just leave it completely open, obviously, sitting next to a trash can. Obviously, self-evidently, any contents (clothes you don't want etc) throw them away in a trash can separately. Sure, you could ask at the help desk, they would say "leave it by that trash can over there" or they'd take it from you and do the same thing.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
9
Fattie makes a good point about there being luggage shops of some description in most major airports. If you don't want to risk talking to security or real airport personnel (for some irrational fear of being detained, e.g.) then try asking the clerk at the luggage shop what to do with an old bag you don't want anymore. They probably get that specific issue more than most anyway.
– Steve-O
14 hours ago
5
@fattie please post your answers as answers instead of comments
– Kat
11 hours ago
add a comment |
The fundamental problem is that what you want to do - leave a bag somewhere and depart without having it associated with you - is exactly what a bomber would want to do. Therefore, I do not believe there is any way to do this without risking being mistaken for a bomber. A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security, so I would not expect that to be a less conspicuous place for your scheme.
I think that trying to leave a bag at an airport will inherently cause a security scare. If you are stopped at the scene, it will be unpleasant. Hong Kong airport police carry submachine guns.. If not, even if it is found out that your bag was harmless, you may be suspected of intentionally leaving your bag to cause a panic. Given the heavy surveillance normally found at airports, it is quite likely they will be able to identify you, and you may face legal trouble.
I would strongly advise against doing anything of the sort. Suck it up, take the bag away with you, and dispose of it in a less sensitive place, far away from the airport.
18
A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security
Can you? I don't know the specifics of the Hong Kong airport, but for the airports I know you can only get to the baggage belt if you get out of a plane or got through check-in, in which case all your possessions have already been scanned and deemed safe. At some point after the baggage belt, there is always a one-way exit
– KooKiz
21 hours ago
9
Depends on the airport, for domestic flights (no customs) it's not uncommon to be able to meet people at the baggage claim (I did so just last year in San Diego).
– etarion
19 hours ago
4
I'm incredulous at all the anwers that are coming up with the best way to sneakily abandon the bag without anyone realising. This is the exact sort of thing that airport security is watching out for. Once you convince them you aren't a bomber they will consider you a time wasting fool so expect a long delay if not worse. Be aware that in most cases people at point of entry have less rights and can be held or refused entry quite easily. My only issue is that just asking a security person what to do might result in them inspecting the bag and disposing of it for you so try that first..
– Eric Nolan
19 hours ago
13
In my (limited) experience, having baggage belts accessible from the exterior is mostly an US thing, and it's unheard of in Europe and all other countries I have visited.
– Federico Poloni
19 hours ago
12
It's also pretty sh!tty to dump it and expect somebody else to deal with it. It's your bag, you dispose of it. I can't make it any simpler than that.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
Tell a member of airport staff that the bag is broken - perhaps even break off something to do with the handle or a wheel (in a toilet, less visible) as these bags aren't so robust. Tell then you didn't have much in it anyway, and where can you throw it away.
3
If you want to get rid of it at the airport, this is the #1 way to do it. BE OBVIOUS do not try to be subtle about it. Show it to someone official(ish), letting them know and verify for themselves that it is empty and harmless, then ask for the proper location to dispose of it.
– FreeMan
13 hours ago
3
Airports must be used to luggage failing (or even no longer being needed) and needing to be disposed off.
– Willeke♦
13 hours ago
add a comment |
Leave the bag, fully emptied and all pockets opened, next to the largest trash can you can find. A note saying RUBBISH/垃圾 inside would also be nice.
This way it's not going to cause a security scare, and the airport's hassle of disposing it will be minimal. It's still basically littering though, and the right thing to do would be bring the bag to somewhere else where it can be properly disposed of.
Or put the things that fit into the bin, then take the empty bag into a toilet stall. Wait a bit, and leave it open and empty in the stall.
– WGroleau
yesterday
32
Open bag, left in a stall? Immediate security alert. You're naively assuming that if it appears empty, it'll be considered obviously empty. But devices that appear harmless are widely used in insurgency/terrorism, it could be a bomb in the lining, triggered by the act of lifting an apparently "empty" bag. And you'll be on CCTV records going in with, and coming out without. Hard to explain.
– Stilez
20 hours ago
2
@WGroleau that's a very easy way to cause a security scare and then get a good cavity search if security notices you doing that
– J.Doe
18 hours ago
1
Thank God, the actual correct answer!
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@pipe The airport I live near frequently broadcasts a message specifically telling everyone to notify security of unattended baggage.
– Captain Man
13 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
I would recommend taking the bag to lost property. You can either tell them the truth or tell them you found it. That way you won't cause a security scare, and the bag may get a new owner.
12
I don't see any reason for OP to "tell them [he] found it" or tell them anything other than the truth, if he chooses to do this. It would be a pointless lie.
– V2Blast
21 hours ago
8
Isn't "Hi, I found this abandoned bag, and decided to jostle it about and bring it right in front of you instead of leaving it alone and tucked out of the way" more likely to cause a scare?
– Chronocidal
20 hours ago
@Chronocidal No, because if it was going to explode it would already have done so. Plus it's obviously empty.
– DJClayworth
15 hours ago
9
Yeah - don't tell them you found it. They will ask you where and when (so they can review who left it). Now you have to tell another lie and this is one that they will be checking with CCTV. Then they figure out you're lying and wonder why. Then the fun starts...
– Dancrumb
15 hours ago
@DJClayworth Hidden in the lining, and a time-delay on the trigger? "Looks Empty" is a fairly simple tactic to devise
– Chronocidal
12 hours ago
add a comment |
Take it out of the airport - I know, a bit more lugging than you'd like, and offer it to homeless folks who might actually be able to get good use out of it.
add a comment |
How do you dispose of a bag at airport A without creating a hassle for yourself and the airport staff?
You send an email to airport A's customer service and ask them how they would like you to handle the situation.
Just explain to them that you want to get rid of the carry-on bag, and a few things you do not need anymore either, after you have gotten your luggage after the flight and ask them where do you leave your no longer useful bag?
Remember that many countries have restriction on items, food etc., that they do not want into their country, these items have to be thrown away in the appropiate bins for destruction, not left around in an unaccompanied bag.
add a comment |
Many of the current answers focus on bomb/terrorist-related security concerns, however the first thing that came to my mind upon reading the situation was one of drug smuggling. Security may be concerned that you are abandoning the bag as it (or you) contain illegal substances. As others have mentioned, leaving the bag open and with a note doesn't mean it isn't a security risk and in fact hiding drugs in the lining of suitcases is a common method used by smugglers.
I think l0b0's answer is the best course of action if you absolutely must leave the bag at the airport, but be aware that security may want you to wait while they check the bag for anything illegal. This is a much better solution than risking a misunderstanding by dumping the bag in the airport.
Of course, just taking the bag out of the airport and disposing of it properly would cause the least hassle for you and least concern for airport security.
New contributor
add a comment |
If it is not immediately obvious that there is nothing inside, then it is a potential security risk.
If the case is made from fabric and was checked up until the point of disposal, then you could pack scissors and cut the fabric off, roll it up and throw it away, then bend the frame until it's also small enough to fit in a bin.
Anything else is just turning your problem into someone else's problem.
New contributor
2
That's going to look suspicious on CCTV in the baggage collection area.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
add a comment |
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "273"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});
function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});
}
});
Guest24601 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2ftravel.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f131616%2fbest-way-to-abandon-a-bag-in-hong-kong-airport%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
9 Answers
9
active
oldest
votes
9 Answers
9
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Ask at the airport information desk, lost property, or a luggage shop (thanks @Fattie). They most likely know some way of ensuring the contents gets given to a charity or at least recycled properly.
Subterfuge will at the very least create overhead for the airport personnel, who will have to either destroy the contents safely or hold on to it for a long time before disposing of it. And you really don't want to have to explain yourself to airport security if this spiel is noticed.
21
I think this is the best answer. Why contrive a strange plan to shed the bag surreptitiously instead of walking to a desk (or even to a security officer) and ask "Sorry, but I want to get rid of that bag, where could I drop it off?" An airport has tons of waste to dispose every day, they would know where to put it.
– Dubu
20 hours ago
2
This is the "you-beat-me-to-it" answer. OP, simply explain to security what you explained to us and follow their instructions with them. With.
– Mikey
17 hours ago
10
Disposing of a broken or un-needed luggage at an airport is totally straightforward. Folks commonly buy new luggage at the luggage shops, and dispose of the old one. Just leave it completely open, obviously, sitting next to a trash can. Obviously, self-evidently, any contents (clothes you don't want etc) throw them away in a trash can separately. Sure, you could ask at the help desk, they would say "leave it by that trash can over there" or they'd take it from you and do the same thing.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
9
Fattie makes a good point about there being luggage shops of some description in most major airports. If you don't want to risk talking to security or real airport personnel (for some irrational fear of being detained, e.g.) then try asking the clerk at the luggage shop what to do with an old bag you don't want anymore. They probably get that specific issue more than most anyway.
– Steve-O
14 hours ago
5
@fattie please post your answers as answers instead of comments
– Kat
11 hours ago
add a comment |
Ask at the airport information desk, lost property, or a luggage shop (thanks @Fattie). They most likely know some way of ensuring the contents gets given to a charity or at least recycled properly.
Subterfuge will at the very least create overhead for the airport personnel, who will have to either destroy the contents safely or hold on to it for a long time before disposing of it. And you really don't want to have to explain yourself to airport security if this spiel is noticed.
21
I think this is the best answer. Why contrive a strange plan to shed the bag surreptitiously instead of walking to a desk (or even to a security officer) and ask "Sorry, but I want to get rid of that bag, where could I drop it off?" An airport has tons of waste to dispose every day, they would know where to put it.
– Dubu
20 hours ago
2
This is the "you-beat-me-to-it" answer. OP, simply explain to security what you explained to us and follow their instructions with them. With.
– Mikey
17 hours ago
10
Disposing of a broken or un-needed luggage at an airport is totally straightforward. Folks commonly buy new luggage at the luggage shops, and dispose of the old one. Just leave it completely open, obviously, sitting next to a trash can. Obviously, self-evidently, any contents (clothes you don't want etc) throw them away in a trash can separately. Sure, you could ask at the help desk, they would say "leave it by that trash can over there" or they'd take it from you and do the same thing.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
9
Fattie makes a good point about there being luggage shops of some description in most major airports. If you don't want to risk talking to security or real airport personnel (for some irrational fear of being detained, e.g.) then try asking the clerk at the luggage shop what to do with an old bag you don't want anymore. They probably get that specific issue more than most anyway.
– Steve-O
14 hours ago
5
@fattie please post your answers as answers instead of comments
– Kat
11 hours ago
add a comment |
Ask at the airport information desk, lost property, or a luggage shop (thanks @Fattie). They most likely know some way of ensuring the contents gets given to a charity or at least recycled properly.
Subterfuge will at the very least create overhead for the airport personnel, who will have to either destroy the contents safely or hold on to it for a long time before disposing of it. And you really don't want to have to explain yourself to airport security if this spiel is noticed.
Ask at the airport information desk, lost property, or a luggage shop (thanks @Fattie). They most likely know some way of ensuring the contents gets given to a charity or at least recycled properly.
Subterfuge will at the very least create overhead for the airport personnel, who will have to either destroy the contents safely or hold on to it for a long time before disposing of it. And you really don't want to have to explain yourself to airport security if this spiel is noticed.
edited 8 hours ago
answered 21 hours ago
l0b0l0b0
525138
525138
21
I think this is the best answer. Why contrive a strange plan to shed the bag surreptitiously instead of walking to a desk (or even to a security officer) and ask "Sorry, but I want to get rid of that bag, where could I drop it off?" An airport has tons of waste to dispose every day, they would know where to put it.
– Dubu
20 hours ago
2
This is the "you-beat-me-to-it" answer. OP, simply explain to security what you explained to us and follow their instructions with them. With.
– Mikey
17 hours ago
10
Disposing of a broken or un-needed luggage at an airport is totally straightforward. Folks commonly buy new luggage at the luggage shops, and dispose of the old one. Just leave it completely open, obviously, sitting next to a trash can. Obviously, self-evidently, any contents (clothes you don't want etc) throw them away in a trash can separately. Sure, you could ask at the help desk, they would say "leave it by that trash can over there" or they'd take it from you and do the same thing.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
9
Fattie makes a good point about there being luggage shops of some description in most major airports. If you don't want to risk talking to security or real airport personnel (for some irrational fear of being detained, e.g.) then try asking the clerk at the luggage shop what to do with an old bag you don't want anymore. They probably get that specific issue more than most anyway.
– Steve-O
14 hours ago
5
@fattie please post your answers as answers instead of comments
– Kat
11 hours ago
add a comment |
21
I think this is the best answer. Why contrive a strange plan to shed the bag surreptitiously instead of walking to a desk (or even to a security officer) and ask "Sorry, but I want to get rid of that bag, where could I drop it off?" An airport has tons of waste to dispose every day, they would know where to put it.
– Dubu
20 hours ago
2
This is the "you-beat-me-to-it" answer. OP, simply explain to security what you explained to us and follow their instructions with them. With.
– Mikey
17 hours ago
10
Disposing of a broken or un-needed luggage at an airport is totally straightforward. Folks commonly buy new luggage at the luggage shops, and dispose of the old one. Just leave it completely open, obviously, sitting next to a trash can. Obviously, self-evidently, any contents (clothes you don't want etc) throw them away in a trash can separately. Sure, you could ask at the help desk, they would say "leave it by that trash can over there" or they'd take it from you and do the same thing.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
9
Fattie makes a good point about there being luggage shops of some description in most major airports. If you don't want to risk talking to security or real airport personnel (for some irrational fear of being detained, e.g.) then try asking the clerk at the luggage shop what to do with an old bag you don't want anymore. They probably get that specific issue more than most anyway.
– Steve-O
14 hours ago
5
@fattie please post your answers as answers instead of comments
– Kat
11 hours ago
21
21
I think this is the best answer. Why contrive a strange plan to shed the bag surreptitiously instead of walking to a desk (or even to a security officer) and ask "Sorry, but I want to get rid of that bag, where could I drop it off?" An airport has tons of waste to dispose every day, they would know where to put it.
– Dubu
20 hours ago
I think this is the best answer. Why contrive a strange plan to shed the bag surreptitiously instead of walking to a desk (or even to a security officer) and ask "Sorry, but I want to get rid of that bag, where could I drop it off?" An airport has tons of waste to dispose every day, they would know where to put it.
– Dubu
20 hours ago
2
2
This is the "you-beat-me-to-it" answer. OP, simply explain to security what you explained to us and follow their instructions with them. With.
– Mikey
17 hours ago
This is the "you-beat-me-to-it" answer. OP, simply explain to security what you explained to us and follow their instructions with them. With.
– Mikey
17 hours ago
10
10
Disposing of a broken or un-needed luggage at an airport is totally straightforward. Folks commonly buy new luggage at the luggage shops, and dispose of the old one. Just leave it completely open, obviously, sitting next to a trash can. Obviously, self-evidently, any contents (clothes you don't want etc) throw them away in a trash can separately. Sure, you could ask at the help desk, they would say "leave it by that trash can over there" or they'd take it from you and do the same thing.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
Disposing of a broken or un-needed luggage at an airport is totally straightforward. Folks commonly buy new luggage at the luggage shops, and dispose of the old one. Just leave it completely open, obviously, sitting next to a trash can. Obviously, self-evidently, any contents (clothes you don't want etc) throw them away in a trash can separately. Sure, you could ask at the help desk, they would say "leave it by that trash can over there" or they'd take it from you and do the same thing.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
9
9
Fattie makes a good point about there being luggage shops of some description in most major airports. If you don't want to risk talking to security or real airport personnel (for some irrational fear of being detained, e.g.) then try asking the clerk at the luggage shop what to do with an old bag you don't want anymore. They probably get that specific issue more than most anyway.
– Steve-O
14 hours ago
Fattie makes a good point about there being luggage shops of some description in most major airports. If you don't want to risk talking to security or real airport personnel (for some irrational fear of being detained, e.g.) then try asking the clerk at the luggage shop what to do with an old bag you don't want anymore. They probably get that specific issue more than most anyway.
– Steve-O
14 hours ago
5
5
@fattie please post your answers as answers instead of comments
– Kat
11 hours ago
@fattie please post your answers as answers instead of comments
– Kat
11 hours ago
add a comment |
The fundamental problem is that what you want to do - leave a bag somewhere and depart without having it associated with you - is exactly what a bomber would want to do. Therefore, I do not believe there is any way to do this without risking being mistaken for a bomber. A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security, so I would not expect that to be a less conspicuous place for your scheme.
I think that trying to leave a bag at an airport will inherently cause a security scare. If you are stopped at the scene, it will be unpleasant. Hong Kong airport police carry submachine guns.. If not, even if it is found out that your bag was harmless, you may be suspected of intentionally leaving your bag to cause a panic. Given the heavy surveillance normally found at airports, it is quite likely they will be able to identify you, and you may face legal trouble.
I would strongly advise against doing anything of the sort. Suck it up, take the bag away with you, and dispose of it in a less sensitive place, far away from the airport.
18
A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security
Can you? I don't know the specifics of the Hong Kong airport, but for the airports I know you can only get to the baggage belt if you get out of a plane or got through check-in, in which case all your possessions have already been scanned and deemed safe. At some point after the baggage belt, there is always a one-way exit
– KooKiz
21 hours ago
9
Depends on the airport, for domestic flights (no customs) it's not uncommon to be able to meet people at the baggage claim (I did so just last year in San Diego).
– etarion
19 hours ago
4
I'm incredulous at all the anwers that are coming up with the best way to sneakily abandon the bag without anyone realising. This is the exact sort of thing that airport security is watching out for. Once you convince them you aren't a bomber they will consider you a time wasting fool so expect a long delay if not worse. Be aware that in most cases people at point of entry have less rights and can be held or refused entry quite easily. My only issue is that just asking a security person what to do might result in them inspecting the bag and disposing of it for you so try that first..
– Eric Nolan
19 hours ago
13
In my (limited) experience, having baggage belts accessible from the exterior is mostly an US thing, and it's unheard of in Europe and all other countries I have visited.
– Federico Poloni
19 hours ago
12
It's also pretty sh!tty to dump it and expect somebody else to deal with it. It's your bag, you dispose of it. I can't make it any simpler than that.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
The fundamental problem is that what you want to do - leave a bag somewhere and depart without having it associated with you - is exactly what a bomber would want to do. Therefore, I do not believe there is any way to do this without risking being mistaken for a bomber. A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security, so I would not expect that to be a less conspicuous place for your scheme.
I think that trying to leave a bag at an airport will inherently cause a security scare. If you are stopped at the scene, it will be unpleasant. Hong Kong airport police carry submachine guns.. If not, even if it is found out that your bag was harmless, you may be suspected of intentionally leaving your bag to cause a panic. Given the heavy surveillance normally found at airports, it is quite likely they will be able to identify you, and you may face legal trouble.
I would strongly advise against doing anything of the sort. Suck it up, take the bag away with you, and dispose of it in a less sensitive place, far away from the airport.
18
A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security
Can you? I don't know the specifics of the Hong Kong airport, but for the airports I know you can only get to the baggage belt if you get out of a plane or got through check-in, in which case all your possessions have already been scanned and deemed safe. At some point after the baggage belt, there is always a one-way exit
– KooKiz
21 hours ago
9
Depends on the airport, for domestic flights (no customs) it's not uncommon to be able to meet people at the baggage claim (I did so just last year in San Diego).
– etarion
19 hours ago
4
I'm incredulous at all the anwers that are coming up with the best way to sneakily abandon the bag without anyone realising. This is the exact sort of thing that airport security is watching out for. Once you convince them you aren't a bomber they will consider you a time wasting fool so expect a long delay if not worse. Be aware that in most cases people at point of entry have less rights and can be held or refused entry quite easily. My only issue is that just asking a security person what to do might result in them inspecting the bag and disposing of it for you so try that first..
– Eric Nolan
19 hours ago
13
In my (limited) experience, having baggage belts accessible from the exterior is mostly an US thing, and it's unheard of in Europe and all other countries I have visited.
– Federico Poloni
19 hours ago
12
It's also pretty sh!tty to dump it and expect somebody else to deal with it. It's your bag, you dispose of it. I can't make it any simpler than that.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
The fundamental problem is that what you want to do - leave a bag somewhere and depart without having it associated with you - is exactly what a bomber would want to do. Therefore, I do not believe there is any way to do this without risking being mistaken for a bomber. A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security, so I would not expect that to be a less conspicuous place for your scheme.
I think that trying to leave a bag at an airport will inherently cause a security scare. If you are stopped at the scene, it will be unpleasant. Hong Kong airport police carry submachine guns.. If not, even if it is found out that your bag was harmless, you may be suspected of intentionally leaving your bag to cause a panic. Given the heavy surveillance normally found at airports, it is quite likely they will be able to identify you, and you may face legal trouble.
I would strongly advise against doing anything of the sort. Suck it up, take the bag away with you, and dispose of it in a less sensitive place, far away from the airport.
The fundamental problem is that what you want to do - leave a bag somewhere and depart without having it associated with you - is exactly what a bomber would want to do. Therefore, I do not believe there is any way to do this without risking being mistaken for a bomber. A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security, so I would not expect that to be a less conspicuous place for your scheme.
I think that trying to leave a bag at an airport will inherently cause a security scare. If you are stopped at the scene, it will be unpleasant. Hong Kong airport police carry submachine guns.. If not, even if it is found out that your bag was harmless, you may be suspected of intentionally leaving your bag to cause a panic. Given the heavy surveillance normally found at airports, it is quite likely they will be able to identify you, and you may face legal trouble.
I would strongly advise against doing anything of the sort. Suck it up, take the bag away with you, and dispose of it in a less sensitive place, far away from the airport.
answered yesterday
Nate EldredgeNate Eldredge
22.7k782107
22.7k782107
18
A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security
Can you? I don't know the specifics of the Hong Kong airport, but for the airports I know you can only get to the baggage belt if you get out of a plane or got through check-in, in which case all your possessions have already been scanned and deemed safe. At some point after the baggage belt, there is always a one-way exit
– KooKiz
21 hours ago
9
Depends on the airport, for domestic flights (no customs) it's not uncommon to be able to meet people at the baggage claim (I did so just last year in San Diego).
– etarion
19 hours ago
4
I'm incredulous at all the anwers that are coming up with the best way to sneakily abandon the bag without anyone realising. This is the exact sort of thing that airport security is watching out for. Once you convince them you aren't a bomber they will consider you a time wasting fool so expect a long delay if not worse. Be aware that in most cases people at point of entry have less rights and can be held or refused entry quite easily. My only issue is that just asking a security person what to do might result in them inspecting the bag and disposing of it for you so try that first..
– Eric Nolan
19 hours ago
13
In my (limited) experience, having baggage belts accessible from the exterior is mostly an US thing, and it's unheard of in Europe and all other countries I have visited.
– Federico Poloni
19 hours ago
12
It's also pretty sh!tty to dump it and expect somebody else to deal with it. It's your bag, you dispose of it. I can't make it any simpler than that.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
18
A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security
Can you? I don't know the specifics of the Hong Kong airport, but for the airports I know you can only get to the baggage belt if you get out of a plane or got through check-in, in which case all your possessions have already been scanned and deemed safe. At some point after the baggage belt, there is always a one-way exit
– KooKiz
21 hours ago
9
Depends on the airport, for domestic flights (no customs) it's not uncommon to be able to meet people at the baggage claim (I did so just last year in San Diego).
– etarion
19 hours ago
4
I'm incredulous at all the anwers that are coming up with the best way to sneakily abandon the bag without anyone realising. This is the exact sort of thing that airport security is watching out for. Once you convince them you aren't a bomber they will consider you a time wasting fool so expect a long delay if not worse. Be aware that in most cases people at point of entry have less rights and can be held or refused entry quite easily. My only issue is that just asking a security person what to do might result in them inspecting the bag and disposing of it for you so try that first..
– Eric Nolan
19 hours ago
13
In my (limited) experience, having baggage belts accessible from the exterior is mostly an US thing, and it's unheard of in Europe and all other countries I have visited.
– Federico Poloni
19 hours ago
12
It's also pretty sh!tty to dump it and expect somebody else to deal with it. It's your bag, you dispose of it. I can't make it any simpler than that.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
18
18
A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security
Can you? I don't know the specifics of the Hong Kong airport, but for the airports I know you can only get to the baggage belt if you get out of a plane or got through check-in, in which case all your possessions have already been scanned and deemed safe. At some point after the baggage belt, there is always a one-way exit– KooKiz
21 hours ago
A baggage belt would be a particularly good target for a bomber since there are lots of people crowding around, and you can get stuff there without going through security
Can you? I don't know the specifics of the Hong Kong airport, but for the airports I know you can only get to the baggage belt if you get out of a plane or got through check-in, in which case all your possessions have already been scanned and deemed safe. At some point after the baggage belt, there is always a one-way exit– KooKiz
21 hours ago
9
9
Depends on the airport, for domestic flights (no customs) it's not uncommon to be able to meet people at the baggage claim (I did so just last year in San Diego).
– etarion
19 hours ago
Depends on the airport, for domestic flights (no customs) it's not uncommon to be able to meet people at the baggage claim (I did so just last year in San Diego).
– etarion
19 hours ago
4
4
I'm incredulous at all the anwers that are coming up with the best way to sneakily abandon the bag without anyone realising. This is the exact sort of thing that airport security is watching out for. Once you convince them you aren't a bomber they will consider you a time wasting fool so expect a long delay if not worse. Be aware that in most cases people at point of entry have less rights and can be held or refused entry quite easily. My only issue is that just asking a security person what to do might result in them inspecting the bag and disposing of it for you so try that first..
– Eric Nolan
19 hours ago
I'm incredulous at all the anwers that are coming up with the best way to sneakily abandon the bag without anyone realising. This is the exact sort of thing that airport security is watching out for. Once you convince them you aren't a bomber they will consider you a time wasting fool so expect a long delay if not worse. Be aware that in most cases people at point of entry have less rights and can be held or refused entry quite easily. My only issue is that just asking a security person what to do might result in them inspecting the bag and disposing of it for you so try that first..
– Eric Nolan
19 hours ago
13
13
In my (limited) experience, having baggage belts accessible from the exterior is mostly an US thing, and it's unheard of in Europe and all other countries I have visited.
– Federico Poloni
19 hours ago
In my (limited) experience, having baggage belts accessible from the exterior is mostly an US thing, and it's unheard of in Europe and all other countries I have visited.
– Federico Poloni
19 hours ago
12
12
It's also pretty sh!tty to dump it and expect somebody else to deal with it. It's your bag, you dispose of it. I can't make it any simpler than that.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
It's also pretty sh!tty to dump it and expect somebody else to deal with it. It's your bag, you dispose of it. I can't make it any simpler than that.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
|
show 7 more comments
Tell a member of airport staff that the bag is broken - perhaps even break off something to do with the handle or a wheel (in a toilet, less visible) as these bags aren't so robust. Tell then you didn't have much in it anyway, and where can you throw it away.
3
If you want to get rid of it at the airport, this is the #1 way to do it. BE OBVIOUS do not try to be subtle about it. Show it to someone official(ish), letting them know and verify for themselves that it is empty and harmless, then ask for the proper location to dispose of it.
– FreeMan
13 hours ago
3
Airports must be used to luggage failing (or even no longer being needed) and needing to be disposed off.
– Willeke♦
13 hours ago
add a comment |
Tell a member of airport staff that the bag is broken - perhaps even break off something to do with the handle or a wheel (in a toilet, less visible) as these bags aren't so robust. Tell then you didn't have much in it anyway, and where can you throw it away.
3
If you want to get rid of it at the airport, this is the #1 way to do it. BE OBVIOUS do not try to be subtle about it. Show it to someone official(ish), letting them know and verify for themselves that it is empty and harmless, then ask for the proper location to dispose of it.
– FreeMan
13 hours ago
3
Airports must be used to luggage failing (or even no longer being needed) and needing to be disposed off.
– Willeke♦
13 hours ago
add a comment |
Tell a member of airport staff that the bag is broken - perhaps even break off something to do with the handle or a wheel (in a toilet, less visible) as these bags aren't so robust. Tell then you didn't have much in it anyway, and where can you throw it away.
Tell a member of airport staff that the bag is broken - perhaps even break off something to do with the handle or a wheel (in a toilet, less visible) as these bags aren't so robust. Tell then you didn't have much in it anyway, and where can you throw it away.
answered 22 hours ago
StilezStilez
91437
91437
3
If you want to get rid of it at the airport, this is the #1 way to do it. BE OBVIOUS do not try to be subtle about it. Show it to someone official(ish), letting them know and verify for themselves that it is empty and harmless, then ask for the proper location to dispose of it.
– FreeMan
13 hours ago
3
Airports must be used to luggage failing (or even no longer being needed) and needing to be disposed off.
– Willeke♦
13 hours ago
add a comment |
3
If you want to get rid of it at the airport, this is the #1 way to do it. BE OBVIOUS do not try to be subtle about it. Show it to someone official(ish), letting them know and verify for themselves that it is empty and harmless, then ask for the proper location to dispose of it.
– FreeMan
13 hours ago
3
Airports must be used to luggage failing (or even no longer being needed) and needing to be disposed off.
– Willeke♦
13 hours ago
3
3
If you want to get rid of it at the airport, this is the #1 way to do it. BE OBVIOUS do not try to be subtle about it. Show it to someone official(ish), letting them know and verify for themselves that it is empty and harmless, then ask for the proper location to dispose of it.
– FreeMan
13 hours ago
If you want to get rid of it at the airport, this is the #1 way to do it. BE OBVIOUS do not try to be subtle about it. Show it to someone official(ish), letting them know and verify for themselves that it is empty and harmless, then ask for the proper location to dispose of it.
– FreeMan
13 hours ago
3
3
Airports must be used to luggage failing (or even no longer being needed) and needing to be disposed off.
– Willeke♦
13 hours ago
Airports must be used to luggage failing (or even no longer being needed) and needing to be disposed off.
– Willeke♦
13 hours ago
add a comment |
Leave the bag, fully emptied and all pockets opened, next to the largest trash can you can find. A note saying RUBBISH/垃圾 inside would also be nice.
This way it's not going to cause a security scare, and the airport's hassle of disposing it will be minimal. It's still basically littering though, and the right thing to do would be bring the bag to somewhere else where it can be properly disposed of.
Or put the things that fit into the bin, then take the empty bag into a toilet stall. Wait a bit, and leave it open and empty in the stall.
– WGroleau
yesterday
32
Open bag, left in a stall? Immediate security alert. You're naively assuming that if it appears empty, it'll be considered obviously empty. But devices that appear harmless are widely used in insurgency/terrorism, it could be a bomb in the lining, triggered by the act of lifting an apparently "empty" bag. And you'll be on CCTV records going in with, and coming out without. Hard to explain.
– Stilez
20 hours ago
2
@WGroleau that's a very easy way to cause a security scare and then get a good cavity search if security notices you doing that
– J.Doe
18 hours ago
1
Thank God, the actual correct answer!
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@pipe The airport I live near frequently broadcasts a message specifically telling everyone to notify security of unattended baggage.
– Captain Man
13 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
Leave the bag, fully emptied and all pockets opened, next to the largest trash can you can find. A note saying RUBBISH/垃圾 inside would also be nice.
This way it's not going to cause a security scare, and the airport's hassle of disposing it will be minimal. It's still basically littering though, and the right thing to do would be bring the bag to somewhere else where it can be properly disposed of.
Or put the things that fit into the bin, then take the empty bag into a toilet stall. Wait a bit, and leave it open and empty in the stall.
– WGroleau
yesterday
32
Open bag, left in a stall? Immediate security alert. You're naively assuming that if it appears empty, it'll be considered obviously empty. But devices that appear harmless are widely used in insurgency/terrorism, it could be a bomb in the lining, triggered by the act of lifting an apparently "empty" bag. And you'll be on CCTV records going in with, and coming out without. Hard to explain.
– Stilez
20 hours ago
2
@WGroleau that's a very easy way to cause a security scare and then get a good cavity search if security notices you doing that
– J.Doe
18 hours ago
1
Thank God, the actual correct answer!
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@pipe The airport I live near frequently broadcasts a message specifically telling everyone to notify security of unattended baggage.
– Captain Man
13 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
Leave the bag, fully emptied and all pockets opened, next to the largest trash can you can find. A note saying RUBBISH/垃圾 inside would also be nice.
This way it's not going to cause a security scare, and the airport's hassle of disposing it will be minimal. It's still basically littering though, and the right thing to do would be bring the bag to somewhere else where it can be properly disposed of.
Leave the bag, fully emptied and all pockets opened, next to the largest trash can you can find. A note saying RUBBISH/垃圾 inside would also be nice.
This way it's not going to cause a security scare, and the airport's hassle of disposing it will be minimal. It's still basically littering though, and the right thing to do would be bring the bag to somewhere else where it can be properly disposed of.
edited yesterday
answered yesterday
jpatokaljpatokal
115k18356517
115k18356517
Or put the things that fit into the bin, then take the empty bag into a toilet stall. Wait a bit, and leave it open and empty in the stall.
– WGroleau
yesterday
32
Open bag, left in a stall? Immediate security alert. You're naively assuming that if it appears empty, it'll be considered obviously empty. But devices that appear harmless are widely used in insurgency/terrorism, it could be a bomb in the lining, triggered by the act of lifting an apparently "empty" bag. And you'll be on CCTV records going in with, and coming out without. Hard to explain.
– Stilez
20 hours ago
2
@WGroleau that's a very easy way to cause a security scare and then get a good cavity search if security notices you doing that
– J.Doe
18 hours ago
1
Thank God, the actual correct answer!
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@pipe The airport I live near frequently broadcasts a message specifically telling everyone to notify security of unattended baggage.
– Captain Man
13 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
Or put the things that fit into the bin, then take the empty bag into a toilet stall. Wait a bit, and leave it open and empty in the stall.
– WGroleau
yesterday
32
Open bag, left in a stall? Immediate security alert. You're naively assuming that if it appears empty, it'll be considered obviously empty. But devices that appear harmless are widely used in insurgency/terrorism, it could be a bomb in the lining, triggered by the act of lifting an apparently "empty" bag. And you'll be on CCTV records going in with, and coming out without. Hard to explain.
– Stilez
20 hours ago
2
@WGroleau that's a very easy way to cause a security scare and then get a good cavity search if security notices you doing that
– J.Doe
18 hours ago
1
Thank God, the actual correct answer!
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@pipe The airport I live near frequently broadcasts a message specifically telling everyone to notify security of unattended baggage.
– Captain Man
13 hours ago
Or put the things that fit into the bin, then take the empty bag into a toilet stall. Wait a bit, and leave it open and empty in the stall.
– WGroleau
yesterday
Or put the things that fit into the bin, then take the empty bag into a toilet stall. Wait a bit, and leave it open and empty in the stall.
– WGroleau
yesterday
32
32
Open bag, left in a stall? Immediate security alert. You're naively assuming that if it appears empty, it'll be considered obviously empty. But devices that appear harmless are widely used in insurgency/terrorism, it could be a bomb in the lining, triggered by the act of lifting an apparently "empty" bag. And you'll be on CCTV records going in with, and coming out without. Hard to explain.
– Stilez
20 hours ago
Open bag, left in a stall? Immediate security alert. You're naively assuming that if it appears empty, it'll be considered obviously empty. But devices that appear harmless are widely used in insurgency/terrorism, it could be a bomb in the lining, triggered by the act of lifting an apparently "empty" bag. And you'll be on CCTV records going in with, and coming out without. Hard to explain.
– Stilez
20 hours ago
2
2
@WGroleau that's a very easy way to cause a security scare and then get a good cavity search if security notices you doing that
– J.Doe
18 hours ago
@WGroleau that's a very easy way to cause a security scare and then get a good cavity search if security notices you doing that
– J.Doe
18 hours ago
1
1
Thank God, the actual correct answer!
– Fattie
16 hours ago
Thank God, the actual correct answer!
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
3
@pipe The airport I live near frequently broadcasts a message specifically telling everyone to notify security of unattended baggage.
– Captain Man
13 hours ago
@pipe The airport I live near frequently broadcasts a message specifically telling everyone to notify security of unattended baggage.
– Captain Man
13 hours ago
|
show 1 more comment
I would recommend taking the bag to lost property. You can either tell them the truth or tell them you found it. That way you won't cause a security scare, and the bag may get a new owner.
12
I don't see any reason for OP to "tell them [he] found it" or tell them anything other than the truth, if he chooses to do this. It would be a pointless lie.
– V2Blast
21 hours ago
8
Isn't "Hi, I found this abandoned bag, and decided to jostle it about and bring it right in front of you instead of leaving it alone and tucked out of the way" more likely to cause a scare?
– Chronocidal
20 hours ago
@Chronocidal No, because if it was going to explode it would already have done so. Plus it's obviously empty.
– DJClayworth
15 hours ago
9
Yeah - don't tell them you found it. They will ask you where and when (so they can review who left it). Now you have to tell another lie and this is one that they will be checking with CCTV. Then they figure out you're lying and wonder why. Then the fun starts...
– Dancrumb
15 hours ago
@DJClayworth Hidden in the lining, and a time-delay on the trigger? "Looks Empty" is a fairly simple tactic to devise
– Chronocidal
12 hours ago
add a comment |
I would recommend taking the bag to lost property. You can either tell them the truth or tell them you found it. That way you won't cause a security scare, and the bag may get a new owner.
12
I don't see any reason for OP to "tell them [he] found it" or tell them anything other than the truth, if he chooses to do this. It would be a pointless lie.
– V2Blast
21 hours ago
8
Isn't "Hi, I found this abandoned bag, and decided to jostle it about and bring it right in front of you instead of leaving it alone and tucked out of the way" more likely to cause a scare?
– Chronocidal
20 hours ago
@Chronocidal No, because if it was going to explode it would already have done so. Plus it's obviously empty.
– DJClayworth
15 hours ago
9
Yeah - don't tell them you found it. They will ask you where and when (so they can review who left it). Now you have to tell another lie and this is one that they will be checking with CCTV. Then they figure out you're lying and wonder why. Then the fun starts...
– Dancrumb
15 hours ago
@DJClayworth Hidden in the lining, and a time-delay on the trigger? "Looks Empty" is a fairly simple tactic to devise
– Chronocidal
12 hours ago
add a comment |
I would recommend taking the bag to lost property. You can either tell them the truth or tell them you found it. That way you won't cause a security scare, and the bag may get a new owner.
I would recommend taking the bag to lost property. You can either tell them the truth or tell them you found it. That way you won't cause a security scare, and the bag may get a new owner.
answered yesterday
DJClayworthDJClayworth
34.1k786125
34.1k786125
12
I don't see any reason for OP to "tell them [he] found it" or tell them anything other than the truth, if he chooses to do this. It would be a pointless lie.
– V2Blast
21 hours ago
8
Isn't "Hi, I found this abandoned bag, and decided to jostle it about and bring it right in front of you instead of leaving it alone and tucked out of the way" more likely to cause a scare?
– Chronocidal
20 hours ago
@Chronocidal No, because if it was going to explode it would already have done so. Plus it's obviously empty.
– DJClayworth
15 hours ago
9
Yeah - don't tell them you found it. They will ask you where and when (so they can review who left it). Now you have to tell another lie and this is one that they will be checking with CCTV. Then they figure out you're lying and wonder why. Then the fun starts...
– Dancrumb
15 hours ago
@DJClayworth Hidden in the lining, and a time-delay on the trigger? "Looks Empty" is a fairly simple tactic to devise
– Chronocidal
12 hours ago
add a comment |
12
I don't see any reason for OP to "tell them [he] found it" or tell them anything other than the truth, if he chooses to do this. It would be a pointless lie.
– V2Blast
21 hours ago
8
Isn't "Hi, I found this abandoned bag, and decided to jostle it about and bring it right in front of you instead of leaving it alone and tucked out of the way" more likely to cause a scare?
– Chronocidal
20 hours ago
@Chronocidal No, because if it was going to explode it would already have done so. Plus it's obviously empty.
– DJClayworth
15 hours ago
9
Yeah - don't tell them you found it. They will ask you where and when (so they can review who left it). Now you have to tell another lie and this is one that they will be checking with CCTV. Then they figure out you're lying and wonder why. Then the fun starts...
– Dancrumb
15 hours ago
@DJClayworth Hidden in the lining, and a time-delay on the trigger? "Looks Empty" is a fairly simple tactic to devise
– Chronocidal
12 hours ago
12
12
I don't see any reason for OP to "tell them [he] found it" or tell them anything other than the truth, if he chooses to do this. It would be a pointless lie.
– V2Blast
21 hours ago
I don't see any reason for OP to "tell them [he] found it" or tell them anything other than the truth, if he chooses to do this. It would be a pointless lie.
– V2Blast
21 hours ago
8
8
Isn't "Hi, I found this abandoned bag, and decided to jostle it about and bring it right in front of you instead of leaving it alone and tucked out of the way" more likely to cause a scare?
– Chronocidal
20 hours ago
Isn't "Hi, I found this abandoned bag, and decided to jostle it about and bring it right in front of you instead of leaving it alone and tucked out of the way" more likely to cause a scare?
– Chronocidal
20 hours ago
@Chronocidal No, because if it was going to explode it would already have done so. Plus it's obviously empty.
– DJClayworth
15 hours ago
@Chronocidal No, because if it was going to explode it would already have done so. Plus it's obviously empty.
– DJClayworth
15 hours ago
9
9
Yeah - don't tell them you found it. They will ask you where and when (so they can review who left it). Now you have to tell another lie and this is one that they will be checking with CCTV. Then they figure out you're lying and wonder why. Then the fun starts...
– Dancrumb
15 hours ago
Yeah - don't tell them you found it. They will ask you where and when (so they can review who left it). Now you have to tell another lie and this is one that they will be checking with CCTV. Then they figure out you're lying and wonder why. Then the fun starts...
– Dancrumb
15 hours ago
@DJClayworth Hidden in the lining, and a time-delay on the trigger? "Looks Empty" is a fairly simple tactic to devise
– Chronocidal
12 hours ago
@DJClayworth Hidden in the lining, and a time-delay on the trigger? "Looks Empty" is a fairly simple tactic to devise
– Chronocidal
12 hours ago
add a comment |
Take it out of the airport - I know, a bit more lugging than you'd like, and offer it to homeless folks who might actually be able to get good use out of it.
add a comment |
Take it out of the airport - I know, a bit more lugging than you'd like, and offer it to homeless folks who might actually be able to get good use out of it.
add a comment |
Take it out of the airport - I know, a bit more lugging than you'd like, and offer it to homeless folks who might actually be able to get good use out of it.
Take it out of the airport - I know, a bit more lugging than you'd like, and offer it to homeless folks who might actually be able to get good use out of it.
answered 15 hours ago
WBTWBT
1,54811329
1,54811329
add a comment |
add a comment |
How do you dispose of a bag at airport A without creating a hassle for yourself and the airport staff?
You send an email to airport A's customer service and ask them how they would like you to handle the situation.
Just explain to them that you want to get rid of the carry-on bag, and a few things you do not need anymore either, after you have gotten your luggage after the flight and ask them where do you leave your no longer useful bag?
Remember that many countries have restriction on items, food etc., that they do not want into their country, these items have to be thrown away in the appropiate bins for destruction, not left around in an unaccompanied bag.
add a comment |
How do you dispose of a bag at airport A without creating a hassle for yourself and the airport staff?
You send an email to airport A's customer service and ask them how they would like you to handle the situation.
Just explain to them that you want to get rid of the carry-on bag, and a few things you do not need anymore either, after you have gotten your luggage after the flight and ask them where do you leave your no longer useful bag?
Remember that many countries have restriction on items, food etc., that they do not want into their country, these items have to be thrown away in the appropiate bins for destruction, not left around in an unaccompanied bag.
add a comment |
How do you dispose of a bag at airport A without creating a hassle for yourself and the airport staff?
You send an email to airport A's customer service and ask them how they would like you to handle the situation.
Just explain to them that you want to get rid of the carry-on bag, and a few things you do not need anymore either, after you have gotten your luggage after the flight and ask them where do you leave your no longer useful bag?
Remember that many countries have restriction on items, food etc., that they do not want into their country, these items have to be thrown away in the appropiate bins for destruction, not left around in an unaccompanied bag.
How do you dispose of a bag at airport A without creating a hassle for yourself and the airport staff?
You send an email to airport A's customer service and ask them how they would like you to handle the situation.
Just explain to them that you want to get rid of the carry-on bag, and a few things you do not need anymore either, after you have gotten your luggage after the flight and ask them where do you leave your no longer useful bag?
Remember that many countries have restriction on items, food etc., that they do not want into their country, these items have to be thrown away in the appropiate bins for destruction, not left around in an unaccompanied bag.
answered 17 hours ago
BentBent
78659
78659
add a comment |
add a comment |
Many of the current answers focus on bomb/terrorist-related security concerns, however the first thing that came to my mind upon reading the situation was one of drug smuggling. Security may be concerned that you are abandoning the bag as it (or you) contain illegal substances. As others have mentioned, leaving the bag open and with a note doesn't mean it isn't a security risk and in fact hiding drugs in the lining of suitcases is a common method used by smugglers.
I think l0b0's answer is the best course of action if you absolutely must leave the bag at the airport, but be aware that security may want you to wait while they check the bag for anything illegal. This is a much better solution than risking a misunderstanding by dumping the bag in the airport.
Of course, just taking the bag out of the airport and disposing of it properly would cause the least hassle for you and least concern for airport security.
New contributor
add a comment |
Many of the current answers focus on bomb/terrorist-related security concerns, however the first thing that came to my mind upon reading the situation was one of drug smuggling. Security may be concerned that you are abandoning the bag as it (or you) contain illegal substances. As others have mentioned, leaving the bag open and with a note doesn't mean it isn't a security risk and in fact hiding drugs in the lining of suitcases is a common method used by smugglers.
I think l0b0's answer is the best course of action if you absolutely must leave the bag at the airport, but be aware that security may want you to wait while they check the bag for anything illegal. This is a much better solution than risking a misunderstanding by dumping the bag in the airport.
Of course, just taking the bag out of the airport and disposing of it properly would cause the least hassle for you and least concern for airport security.
New contributor
add a comment |
Many of the current answers focus on bomb/terrorist-related security concerns, however the first thing that came to my mind upon reading the situation was one of drug smuggling. Security may be concerned that you are abandoning the bag as it (or you) contain illegal substances. As others have mentioned, leaving the bag open and with a note doesn't mean it isn't a security risk and in fact hiding drugs in the lining of suitcases is a common method used by smugglers.
I think l0b0's answer is the best course of action if you absolutely must leave the bag at the airport, but be aware that security may want you to wait while they check the bag for anything illegal. This is a much better solution than risking a misunderstanding by dumping the bag in the airport.
Of course, just taking the bag out of the airport and disposing of it properly would cause the least hassle for you and least concern for airport security.
New contributor
Many of the current answers focus on bomb/terrorist-related security concerns, however the first thing that came to my mind upon reading the situation was one of drug smuggling. Security may be concerned that you are abandoning the bag as it (or you) contain illegal substances. As others have mentioned, leaving the bag open and with a note doesn't mean it isn't a security risk and in fact hiding drugs in the lining of suitcases is a common method used by smugglers.
I think l0b0's answer is the best course of action if you absolutely must leave the bag at the airport, but be aware that security may want you to wait while they check the bag for anything illegal. This is a much better solution than risking a misunderstanding by dumping the bag in the airport.
Of course, just taking the bag out of the airport and disposing of it properly would cause the least hassle for you and least concern for airport security.
New contributor
New contributor
answered 15 hours ago
user91808user91808
211
211
New contributor
New contributor
add a comment |
add a comment |
If it is not immediately obvious that there is nothing inside, then it is a potential security risk.
If the case is made from fabric and was checked up until the point of disposal, then you could pack scissors and cut the fabric off, roll it up and throw it away, then bend the frame until it's also small enough to fit in a bin.
Anything else is just turning your problem into someone else's problem.
New contributor
2
That's going to look suspicious on CCTV in the baggage collection area.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
add a comment |
If it is not immediately obvious that there is nothing inside, then it is a potential security risk.
If the case is made from fabric and was checked up until the point of disposal, then you could pack scissors and cut the fabric off, roll it up and throw it away, then bend the frame until it's also small enough to fit in a bin.
Anything else is just turning your problem into someone else's problem.
New contributor
2
That's going to look suspicious on CCTV in the baggage collection area.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
add a comment |
If it is not immediately obvious that there is nothing inside, then it is a potential security risk.
If the case is made from fabric and was checked up until the point of disposal, then you could pack scissors and cut the fabric off, roll it up and throw it away, then bend the frame until it's also small enough to fit in a bin.
Anything else is just turning your problem into someone else's problem.
New contributor
If it is not immediately obvious that there is nothing inside, then it is a potential security risk.
If the case is made from fabric and was checked up until the point of disposal, then you could pack scissors and cut the fabric off, roll it up and throw it away, then bend the frame until it's also small enough to fit in a bin.
Anything else is just turning your problem into someone else's problem.
New contributor
New contributor
answered 19 hours ago
ButtheadButthead
111
111
New contributor
New contributor
2
That's going to look suspicious on CCTV in the baggage collection area.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
add a comment |
2
That's going to look suspicious on CCTV in the baggage collection area.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
2
2
That's going to look suspicious on CCTV in the baggage collection area.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
That's going to look suspicious on CCTV in the baggage collection area.
– Lightness Races in Orbit
17 hours ago
add a comment |
Guest24601 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Guest24601 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Guest24601 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Guest24601 is a new contributor. Be nice, and check out our Code of Conduct.
Thanks for contributing an answer to Travel Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2ftravel.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f131616%2fbest-way-to-abandon-a-bag-in-hong-kong-airport%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
25
Wouldn't they treat a bag on the carousel without a tag sending it to that airport just like a bag left lying around? The undramatic lost luggage processing is for a bag that has been through security at the airport it came from.
– Patricia Shanahan
yesterday
20
How will you have "main baggage between collecting it from the belt" if you're not checking anything? Consider how this'll look to anyone watching - you're suggesting taking a bag off the baggage belt, moving items between bags, and then putting a bag back on the belt. This will look like you are stealing the contents of the bag to anyone watching...
– Doc
yesterday
6
Instead of a bag, consider using a simple cardboard box.
– Antzi
23 hours ago
34
"My current best plan is to casually drop it onto a loaded baggage belt etc ..". That is utterly ridiculous. Are you joking?! Just leave it OPEN AND EMPTY near a trash can - simple.
– Fattie
16 hours ago
3
@Guest24601 I wouldn't recommend performing surgery on a suitcase and then stuffing it into a bin either. Again, that looks like something that someone up to no good would do. You mention that the bag is not in perfect condition, I doubt you'd be the first person to ask about disposing such an item.
– Richard
15 hours ago