How did Doctor Strange see the winning outcome in Avengers: Infinity War?





.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty{ margin-bottom:0;
}







25















In Doctor Strange we see that the Masters of the Mystic Arts can see into the past and the future, and we know that the Ancient One was able to see into the future as well, but only up to her death. She said herself that in all the possible futures she was never able to get past that point.



So if this is true for the Ancient One, then how did Doctor Strange figure out how Thanos was gonna die/everyone would stay alive in the end if he died before it happened? Does it have something to do with directly using the Time Stone?










share|improve this question




















  • 2





    Hi, welcome to SF&F! I hope you get an answer to this question, but it might be hard to answer based on what is officially (canonically) already known from the movies. If you would consider answers based on comics as well, you might note that in your question.

    – DavidW
    Mar 27 at 15:38






  • 2





    IIRC a very similar question, if not an exact duplicate already exists (though maybe on movie.se). Found the duplicate

    – XtremeBaumer
    Mar 27 at 15:39













  • I found that question actually and while I think this question was pretty similar to it, I actually prefer the accepted answer here. I somehow missed that you can see others futures as well not just your own with the time stone lol.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:18






  • 1





    I am guessing… magic.

    – Lexible
    Mar 28 at 0:40


















25















In Doctor Strange we see that the Masters of the Mystic Arts can see into the past and the future, and we know that the Ancient One was able to see into the future as well, but only up to her death. She said herself that in all the possible futures she was never able to get past that point.



So if this is true for the Ancient One, then how did Doctor Strange figure out how Thanos was gonna die/everyone would stay alive in the end if he died before it happened? Does it have something to do with directly using the Time Stone?










share|improve this question




















  • 2





    Hi, welcome to SF&F! I hope you get an answer to this question, but it might be hard to answer based on what is officially (canonically) already known from the movies. If you would consider answers based on comics as well, you might note that in your question.

    – DavidW
    Mar 27 at 15:38






  • 2





    IIRC a very similar question, if not an exact duplicate already exists (though maybe on movie.se). Found the duplicate

    – XtremeBaumer
    Mar 27 at 15:39













  • I found that question actually and while I think this question was pretty similar to it, I actually prefer the accepted answer here. I somehow missed that you can see others futures as well not just your own with the time stone lol.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:18






  • 1





    I am guessing… magic.

    – Lexible
    Mar 28 at 0:40














25












25








25


2






In Doctor Strange we see that the Masters of the Mystic Arts can see into the past and the future, and we know that the Ancient One was able to see into the future as well, but only up to her death. She said herself that in all the possible futures she was never able to get past that point.



So if this is true for the Ancient One, then how did Doctor Strange figure out how Thanos was gonna die/everyone would stay alive in the end if he died before it happened? Does it have something to do with directly using the Time Stone?










share|improve this question
















In Doctor Strange we see that the Masters of the Mystic Arts can see into the past and the future, and we know that the Ancient One was able to see into the future as well, but only up to her death. She said herself that in all the possible futures she was never able to get past that point.



So if this is true for the Ancient One, then how did Doctor Strange figure out how Thanos was gonna die/everyone would stay alive in the end if he died before it happened? Does it have something to do with directly using the Time Stone?







marvel marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-infinity-war doctor-strange






share|improve this question















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited Mar 27 at 15:38









TheLethalCarrot

50.6k20277318




50.6k20277318










asked Mar 27 at 15:34









B. LalondeB. Lalonde

13124




13124








  • 2





    Hi, welcome to SF&F! I hope you get an answer to this question, but it might be hard to answer based on what is officially (canonically) already known from the movies. If you would consider answers based on comics as well, you might note that in your question.

    – DavidW
    Mar 27 at 15:38






  • 2





    IIRC a very similar question, if not an exact duplicate already exists (though maybe on movie.se). Found the duplicate

    – XtremeBaumer
    Mar 27 at 15:39













  • I found that question actually and while I think this question was pretty similar to it, I actually prefer the accepted answer here. I somehow missed that you can see others futures as well not just your own with the time stone lol.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:18






  • 1





    I am guessing… magic.

    – Lexible
    Mar 28 at 0:40














  • 2





    Hi, welcome to SF&F! I hope you get an answer to this question, but it might be hard to answer based on what is officially (canonically) already known from the movies. If you would consider answers based on comics as well, you might note that in your question.

    – DavidW
    Mar 27 at 15:38






  • 2





    IIRC a very similar question, if not an exact duplicate already exists (though maybe on movie.se). Found the duplicate

    – XtremeBaumer
    Mar 27 at 15:39













  • I found that question actually and while I think this question was pretty similar to it, I actually prefer the accepted answer here. I somehow missed that you can see others futures as well not just your own with the time stone lol.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:18






  • 1





    I am guessing… magic.

    – Lexible
    Mar 28 at 0:40








2




2





Hi, welcome to SF&F! I hope you get an answer to this question, but it might be hard to answer based on what is officially (canonically) already known from the movies. If you would consider answers based on comics as well, you might note that in your question.

– DavidW
Mar 27 at 15:38





Hi, welcome to SF&F! I hope you get an answer to this question, but it might be hard to answer based on what is officially (canonically) already known from the movies. If you would consider answers based on comics as well, you might note that in your question.

– DavidW
Mar 27 at 15:38




2




2





IIRC a very similar question, if not an exact duplicate already exists (though maybe on movie.se). Found the duplicate

– XtremeBaumer
Mar 27 at 15:39







IIRC a very similar question, if not an exact duplicate already exists (though maybe on movie.se). Found the duplicate

– XtremeBaumer
Mar 27 at 15:39















I found that question actually and while I think this question was pretty similar to it, I actually prefer the accepted answer here. I somehow missed that you can see others futures as well not just your own with the time stone lol.

– B. Lalonde
Mar 27 at 16:18





I found that question actually and while I think this question was pretty similar to it, I actually prefer the accepted answer here. I somehow missed that you can see others futures as well not just your own with the time stone lol.

– B. Lalonde
Mar 27 at 16:18




1




1





I am guessing… magic.

– Lexible
Mar 28 at 0:40





I am guessing… magic.

– Lexible
Mar 28 at 0:40










1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes


















31














There doesn't seem to be any contradiction with what we see Doctor Strange do and the quote by The Ancient One. This is the conversation in Doctor Strange:




The Ancient One: I've spent so many years peering through time, looking at this exact moment. But I can't see past it. I've prevented countless terrible futures and after each one there's always another, and they all lead here but never further.



Strange: You think this is where you die.



The Ancient One: You wonder what I see in your future?



Strange: No. Yes.



The Ancient One: I never saw your future, only its possibilities. You have such a capacity for goodness. You've always excelled, but not because you crave success but because of your fear of failure.



Doctor Strange




The Ancient One is looking into her future and can't see past the point where she dies for her own future. However, she can see past the point in Doctor Strange's future and see his possible futures. This is in line with what we see him do in Avengers: Infinity War in that he looks into the possible futures for the whole team and how they win not necessarily his own future.




Doctor Strange: [panting] I went forward in time to view alternate futures. To see all the possible outcomes of the coming conflict.



Peter Quill: How many did you see?



Doctor Strange: 14,000,605.



Tony Stark: How many did we win?



[Strange stares intently at Tony for a moment]



Strange: [pause] One.



Avengers: Infinity War






It's also worth noting that Strange uses the Time Stone to see into the future whereas it appears that The Ancient One doesn't use it and so this likely plays a part in it too.






share|improve this answer





















  • 7





    I'd quibble slightly on the last observation. The Ancient One didn't have the Eye of Agamotto (Time Stone) when this conversation took place, but if anyone could "check it out of the library" for her own meditations over the years, that person would be the Ancient One.

    – Blaze
    Mar 27 at 16:08











  • @Blaze Been a while since I watched Doctor Strange but I had the impression she didn't/wouldn't use it. Could be wrong though, In either case, however, it is mainly a side point here.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    Mar 27 at 16:12






  • 1





    I would hazard a guess that the first time they found the time stone, they tried using it, realized what it was (and subsequently researched the other infinity stones as well), and then agreed that it was too dangerous in anyones hands so they just kept it locked up/guarded it.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:21











  • @B.Lalonde But TAO was known to... dabble... in things she potentially shouldn't have.

    – Möoz
    Mar 28 at 2:33






  • 2





    At least in the comics, the soul stone is known to hold the Soul World, a mini universe inside the stone. If the cinematic universe follows that lead, I (and a lot more people) guess the poeple who were turned to dust are actually inside the stone and not really dead. Thus, Dr. Strange wouldn't be dead and there would be no contradiction.

    – Filipe Nicoli
    Mar 28 at 5:40












Your Answer








StackExchange.ready(function() {
var channelOptions = {
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
};
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);

StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function() {
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled) {
StackExchange.using("snippets", function() {
createEditor();
});
}
else {
createEditor();
}
});

function createEditor() {
StackExchange.prepareEditor({
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader: {
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0/"u003ecc by-sa 3.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
},
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
});


}
});














draft saved

draft discarded


















StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f208020%2fhow-did-doctor-strange-see-the-winning-outcome-in-avengers-infinity-war%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown

























1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes








1 Answer
1






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









31














There doesn't seem to be any contradiction with what we see Doctor Strange do and the quote by The Ancient One. This is the conversation in Doctor Strange:




The Ancient One: I've spent so many years peering through time, looking at this exact moment. But I can't see past it. I've prevented countless terrible futures and after each one there's always another, and they all lead here but never further.



Strange: You think this is where you die.



The Ancient One: You wonder what I see in your future?



Strange: No. Yes.



The Ancient One: I never saw your future, only its possibilities. You have such a capacity for goodness. You've always excelled, but not because you crave success but because of your fear of failure.



Doctor Strange




The Ancient One is looking into her future and can't see past the point where she dies for her own future. However, she can see past the point in Doctor Strange's future and see his possible futures. This is in line with what we see him do in Avengers: Infinity War in that he looks into the possible futures for the whole team and how they win not necessarily his own future.




Doctor Strange: [panting] I went forward in time to view alternate futures. To see all the possible outcomes of the coming conflict.



Peter Quill: How many did you see?



Doctor Strange: 14,000,605.



Tony Stark: How many did we win?



[Strange stares intently at Tony for a moment]



Strange: [pause] One.



Avengers: Infinity War






It's also worth noting that Strange uses the Time Stone to see into the future whereas it appears that The Ancient One doesn't use it and so this likely plays a part in it too.






share|improve this answer





















  • 7





    I'd quibble slightly on the last observation. The Ancient One didn't have the Eye of Agamotto (Time Stone) when this conversation took place, but if anyone could "check it out of the library" for her own meditations over the years, that person would be the Ancient One.

    – Blaze
    Mar 27 at 16:08











  • @Blaze Been a while since I watched Doctor Strange but I had the impression she didn't/wouldn't use it. Could be wrong though, In either case, however, it is mainly a side point here.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    Mar 27 at 16:12






  • 1





    I would hazard a guess that the first time they found the time stone, they tried using it, realized what it was (and subsequently researched the other infinity stones as well), and then agreed that it was too dangerous in anyones hands so they just kept it locked up/guarded it.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:21











  • @B.Lalonde But TAO was known to... dabble... in things she potentially shouldn't have.

    – Möoz
    Mar 28 at 2:33






  • 2





    At least in the comics, the soul stone is known to hold the Soul World, a mini universe inside the stone. If the cinematic universe follows that lead, I (and a lot more people) guess the poeple who were turned to dust are actually inside the stone and not really dead. Thus, Dr. Strange wouldn't be dead and there would be no contradiction.

    – Filipe Nicoli
    Mar 28 at 5:40
















31














There doesn't seem to be any contradiction with what we see Doctor Strange do and the quote by The Ancient One. This is the conversation in Doctor Strange:




The Ancient One: I've spent so many years peering through time, looking at this exact moment. But I can't see past it. I've prevented countless terrible futures and after each one there's always another, and they all lead here but never further.



Strange: You think this is where you die.



The Ancient One: You wonder what I see in your future?



Strange: No. Yes.



The Ancient One: I never saw your future, only its possibilities. You have such a capacity for goodness. You've always excelled, but not because you crave success but because of your fear of failure.



Doctor Strange




The Ancient One is looking into her future and can't see past the point where she dies for her own future. However, she can see past the point in Doctor Strange's future and see his possible futures. This is in line with what we see him do in Avengers: Infinity War in that he looks into the possible futures for the whole team and how they win not necessarily his own future.




Doctor Strange: [panting] I went forward in time to view alternate futures. To see all the possible outcomes of the coming conflict.



Peter Quill: How many did you see?



Doctor Strange: 14,000,605.



Tony Stark: How many did we win?



[Strange stares intently at Tony for a moment]



Strange: [pause] One.



Avengers: Infinity War






It's also worth noting that Strange uses the Time Stone to see into the future whereas it appears that The Ancient One doesn't use it and so this likely plays a part in it too.






share|improve this answer





















  • 7





    I'd quibble slightly on the last observation. The Ancient One didn't have the Eye of Agamotto (Time Stone) when this conversation took place, but if anyone could "check it out of the library" for her own meditations over the years, that person would be the Ancient One.

    – Blaze
    Mar 27 at 16:08











  • @Blaze Been a while since I watched Doctor Strange but I had the impression she didn't/wouldn't use it. Could be wrong though, In either case, however, it is mainly a side point here.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    Mar 27 at 16:12






  • 1





    I would hazard a guess that the first time they found the time stone, they tried using it, realized what it was (and subsequently researched the other infinity stones as well), and then agreed that it was too dangerous in anyones hands so they just kept it locked up/guarded it.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:21











  • @B.Lalonde But TAO was known to... dabble... in things she potentially shouldn't have.

    – Möoz
    Mar 28 at 2:33






  • 2





    At least in the comics, the soul stone is known to hold the Soul World, a mini universe inside the stone. If the cinematic universe follows that lead, I (and a lot more people) guess the poeple who were turned to dust are actually inside the stone and not really dead. Thus, Dr. Strange wouldn't be dead and there would be no contradiction.

    – Filipe Nicoli
    Mar 28 at 5:40














31












31








31







There doesn't seem to be any contradiction with what we see Doctor Strange do and the quote by The Ancient One. This is the conversation in Doctor Strange:




The Ancient One: I've spent so many years peering through time, looking at this exact moment. But I can't see past it. I've prevented countless terrible futures and after each one there's always another, and they all lead here but never further.



Strange: You think this is where you die.



The Ancient One: You wonder what I see in your future?



Strange: No. Yes.



The Ancient One: I never saw your future, only its possibilities. You have such a capacity for goodness. You've always excelled, but not because you crave success but because of your fear of failure.



Doctor Strange




The Ancient One is looking into her future and can't see past the point where she dies for her own future. However, she can see past the point in Doctor Strange's future and see his possible futures. This is in line with what we see him do in Avengers: Infinity War in that he looks into the possible futures for the whole team and how they win not necessarily his own future.




Doctor Strange: [panting] I went forward in time to view alternate futures. To see all the possible outcomes of the coming conflict.



Peter Quill: How many did you see?



Doctor Strange: 14,000,605.



Tony Stark: How many did we win?



[Strange stares intently at Tony for a moment]



Strange: [pause] One.



Avengers: Infinity War






It's also worth noting that Strange uses the Time Stone to see into the future whereas it appears that The Ancient One doesn't use it and so this likely plays a part in it too.






share|improve this answer















There doesn't seem to be any contradiction with what we see Doctor Strange do and the quote by The Ancient One. This is the conversation in Doctor Strange:




The Ancient One: I've spent so many years peering through time, looking at this exact moment. But I can't see past it. I've prevented countless terrible futures and after each one there's always another, and they all lead here but never further.



Strange: You think this is where you die.



The Ancient One: You wonder what I see in your future?



Strange: No. Yes.



The Ancient One: I never saw your future, only its possibilities. You have such a capacity for goodness. You've always excelled, but not because you crave success but because of your fear of failure.



Doctor Strange




The Ancient One is looking into her future and can't see past the point where she dies for her own future. However, she can see past the point in Doctor Strange's future and see his possible futures. This is in line with what we see him do in Avengers: Infinity War in that he looks into the possible futures for the whole team and how they win not necessarily his own future.




Doctor Strange: [panting] I went forward in time to view alternate futures. To see all the possible outcomes of the coming conflict.



Peter Quill: How many did you see?



Doctor Strange: 14,000,605.



Tony Stark: How many did we win?



[Strange stares intently at Tony for a moment]



Strange: [pause] One.



Avengers: Infinity War






It's also worth noting that Strange uses the Time Stone to see into the future whereas it appears that The Ancient One doesn't use it and so this likely plays a part in it too.







share|improve this answer














share|improve this answer



share|improve this answer








edited Mar 28 at 0:42









Lexible

8,07412662




8,07412662










answered Mar 27 at 15:47









TheLethalCarrotTheLethalCarrot

50.6k20277318




50.6k20277318








  • 7





    I'd quibble slightly on the last observation. The Ancient One didn't have the Eye of Agamotto (Time Stone) when this conversation took place, but if anyone could "check it out of the library" for her own meditations over the years, that person would be the Ancient One.

    – Blaze
    Mar 27 at 16:08











  • @Blaze Been a while since I watched Doctor Strange but I had the impression she didn't/wouldn't use it. Could be wrong though, In either case, however, it is mainly a side point here.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    Mar 27 at 16:12






  • 1





    I would hazard a guess that the first time they found the time stone, they tried using it, realized what it was (and subsequently researched the other infinity stones as well), and then agreed that it was too dangerous in anyones hands so they just kept it locked up/guarded it.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:21











  • @B.Lalonde But TAO was known to... dabble... in things she potentially shouldn't have.

    – Möoz
    Mar 28 at 2:33






  • 2





    At least in the comics, the soul stone is known to hold the Soul World, a mini universe inside the stone. If the cinematic universe follows that lead, I (and a lot more people) guess the poeple who were turned to dust are actually inside the stone and not really dead. Thus, Dr. Strange wouldn't be dead and there would be no contradiction.

    – Filipe Nicoli
    Mar 28 at 5:40














  • 7





    I'd quibble slightly on the last observation. The Ancient One didn't have the Eye of Agamotto (Time Stone) when this conversation took place, but if anyone could "check it out of the library" for her own meditations over the years, that person would be the Ancient One.

    – Blaze
    Mar 27 at 16:08











  • @Blaze Been a while since I watched Doctor Strange but I had the impression she didn't/wouldn't use it. Could be wrong though, In either case, however, it is mainly a side point here.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    Mar 27 at 16:12






  • 1





    I would hazard a guess that the first time they found the time stone, they tried using it, realized what it was (and subsequently researched the other infinity stones as well), and then agreed that it was too dangerous in anyones hands so they just kept it locked up/guarded it.

    – B. Lalonde
    Mar 27 at 16:21











  • @B.Lalonde But TAO was known to... dabble... in things she potentially shouldn't have.

    – Möoz
    Mar 28 at 2:33






  • 2





    At least in the comics, the soul stone is known to hold the Soul World, a mini universe inside the stone. If the cinematic universe follows that lead, I (and a lot more people) guess the poeple who were turned to dust are actually inside the stone and not really dead. Thus, Dr. Strange wouldn't be dead and there would be no contradiction.

    – Filipe Nicoli
    Mar 28 at 5:40








7




7





I'd quibble slightly on the last observation. The Ancient One didn't have the Eye of Agamotto (Time Stone) when this conversation took place, but if anyone could "check it out of the library" for her own meditations over the years, that person would be the Ancient One.

– Blaze
Mar 27 at 16:08





I'd quibble slightly on the last observation. The Ancient One didn't have the Eye of Agamotto (Time Stone) when this conversation took place, but if anyone could "check it out of the library" for her own meditations over the years, that person would be the Ancient One.

– Blaze
Mar 27 at 16:08













@Blaze Been a while since I watched Doctor Strange but I had the impression she didn't/wouldn't use it. Could be wrong though, In either case, however, it is mainly a side point here.

– TheLethalCarrot
Mar 27 at 16:12





@Blaze Been a while since I watched Doctor Strange but I had the impression she didn't/wouldn't use it. Could be wrong though, In either case, however, it is mainly a side point here.

– TheLethalCarrot
Mar 27 at 16:12




1




1





I would hazard a guess that the first time they found the time stone, they tried using it, realized what it was (and subsequently researched the other infinity stones as well), and then agreed that it was too dangerous in anyones hands so they just kept it locked up/guarded it.

– B. Lalonde
Mar 27 at 16:21





I would hazard a guess that the first time they found the time stone, they tried using it, realized what it was (and subsequently researched the other infinity stones as well), and then agreed that it was too dangerous in anyones hands so they just kept it locked up/guarded it.

– B. Lalonde
Mar 27 at 16:21













@B.Lalonde But TAO was known to... dabble... in things she potentially shouldn't have.

– Möoz
Mar 28 at 2:33





@B.Lalonde But TAO was known to... dabble... in things she potentially shouldn't have.

– Möoz
Mar 28 at 2:33




2




2





At least in the comics, the soul stone is known to hold the Soul World, a mini universe inside the stone. If the cinematic universe follows that lead, I (and a lot more people) guess the poeple who were turned to dust are actually inside the stone and not really dead. Thus, Dr. Strange wouldn't be dead and there would be no contradiction.

– Filipe Nicoli
Mar 28 at 5:40





At least in the comics, the soul stone is known to hold the Soul World, a mini universe inside the stone. If the cinematic universe follows that lead, I (and a lot more people) guess the poeple who were turned to dust are actually inside the stone and not really dead. Thus, Dr. Strange wouldn't be dead and there would be no contradiction.

– Filipe Nicoli
Mar 28 at 5:40


















draft saved

draft discarded




















































Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!


  • Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!

But avoid



  • Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.

  • Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.


To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.




draft saved


draft discarded














StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f208020%2fhow-did-doctor-strange-see-the-winning-outcome-in-avengers-infinity-war%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);

Post as a guest















Required, but never shown





















































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown

































Required, but never shown














Required, but never shown












Required, but never shown







Required, but never shown







Popular posts from this blog

If I really need a card on my start hand, how many mulligans make sense? [duplicate]

Alcedinidae

Can an atomic nucleus contain both particles and antiparticles? [duplicate]